10-21-2008 Special Meeting
SPECIAL MEETING OF THE ISLE OF WIGHT COUNTY BOARD OF
SUPERVISORS HELD THE TWENTY-FIRST DAY OF OCTOBER IN
THE YEAR TWO THOUSAND AND EIGHT
PRESENT: BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
Stan D. Clark, Chairman
James B. Brown, Jr., Vice-Chairman
Phillip A. Bradshaw
Al Casteen
Thomas J. Wright, III
PRESENT: PLANNING COMMISSION
Lars S. Gordon, Vice-Chairman
Lee Winslett, Jr.
R. L. Walker
Don G. Rosie
Nancy Guill
Rex W. Alphin
James P. O?Briant, III, Chairman
Leah Dempsey
Barbara Easter
Also Attending: A. Paul Burton, Interim County Attorney
W. Douglas Caskey, County Administrator
Patrick J. Small, Assistant County Administrator
Carey Mills Storm, Clerk
Chairman Clark called the special meeting to order at 6:00 p.m. in the
Smithfield Station Conference Room for the purpose of conducting a joint
meeting with the Planning Commission.
//
Supervisor Casteen delivered the invocation.
//
Chairman Clark addressed the sound financial condition of the
County.
Supervisor Bradshaw elaborated that the State is experiencing budget
reductions, which, in turn, will eventually impact the County. He concurred
that the County is in good financial standing, noting that funds have been set
aside in the past in anticipation of leaner years ahead. He noted with respect
to unfunded mandates, the County is faced with having to pick up the cost of
various programs that have been mandated by the State. He further noted
that the County does not have the same taxing authority as cities or towns,
which puts it at a disadvantage.
1
Chairman Clark advised that the State has reduced its funding for
Constitutional Offices, making it difficult on the County, as it now has to
supplement certain positions within those State offices because it has
become accustomed to a certain level of service.
Supervisor Bradshaw remarked that the Virginia Association of
Counties is actively involved legislatively and does recognize the financial
burden being placed on local governments by the State. He recognized the
Planning Commission members, noting that these individuals are a valuable
asset to the County.
//
Beverly H. Walkup, Director of Planning and Zoning, distributed a
handout pertaining to affordable housing. She noted that the final report of
the Isle of Wight County Taskforce on Workforce Housing was accepted by
the Board at its September 20, 2007 meeting with the condition that the
Workforce Housing Program be voluntary as recommended by the Planning
Commission. She noted that the report was a culmination of research
conducted by the consulting firm of Innovative Housing Institute and
members of the Isle of Wight County Task Force. She noted that the
following objectives were met in the final report: The definition of
workforce housing; the need for workforce housing; workforce housing
prices; and, strategies to ensure workforce housing. She noted that the Task
Force had met over a seven (7) month period and studied the housing needs
of the County?s workforce, which included Isle of Wight County
government employees; Town of Smithfield government employees;
Smithfield foods employees; and, International Paper. She noted that the
findings showed that the average cost of new housing in the northern end of
the County ranged from $339,000 to $1,250,000 and that the median price
was $539,000; that the average cost of new housing in Smithfield ranged
from $292,000 to $740,000 and that the median price was $438,000; and,
that the median price of new housing in the southern end of the County was
$315,000. She noted that workforce housing is defined in the County as
32% of gross monthly income, minus extraordinary expenses, which are
multiplied by an interest rate factor current at the time, plus a down payment
and minimum closing costs to the buyer, which equals the price of the
house. She remarked that everyone needs a place to live, regardless of age,
job, race, disability, income or status in life. She recommended that a
variety of housing types and innovative designs be developed in planned
development communities to assist in achieving workforce housing goals
and that the developers of residential and mixed-use projects be encouraged
to include workforce housing proffers in their development proposals. She
commented that increases in residential density are the economic engine that
drives workforce housing, equating to zero land costs for workforce units
and that creative development of clustered housing and use of smaller lot
2
sizes for homes are examples of planning tools that can lower housing costs
and make efficient use of land resources.
The Board concurred that it would discuss whether or not it endorses
the concept of workforce housing in the County, as well as a Housing
Officer position, at its upcoming Board retreat.
//
Ms. Walkup distributed a handout containing the proposed criteria for
the house envelope concept associated with Chesapeake Bay exception
cases. She advised that the concept has been forwarded to the Chesapeake
Bay Local Assistance Department for its review and that she would advise
the Board accordingly when CBLAD?s comments are received by staff.
Chairman Clark requested that Ms. Walkup advise the Board relative
to CBLAD?s standards, which are different for the County.
//
Ms. Walkup distributed copies of information pertaining to the
mandatory requirements of State Mandated Urban Development Areas
(UDA), which were adopted by the General Assembly in 2007 and which
must be approved by July 2011.
//
Jamie Oliver, Planning and Zoning, addressed the status of the Route
58 Master Plan. She advised that staff has developed a draft Land Use Plan
similar to that adopted in the Comprehensive Plan, which includes 40-year
projections for economic growth; home development in Carrsville; and,
certain design guidelines. She advised that the draft Plan is currently being
reviewed by staff and that she anticipates conducting a public hearing on the
proposed Plan by the end of the year.
Supervisor Bradshaw commented that the Board desires to have the
authority to deny borrow pit applications based on the County?s inability to
tax them.
Interim County Attorney Burton advised that the Board has no
authority under the law to levy a tax on borrow pits; however, the Board
could enter into a contract with an applicant to allow the County to collect
this extra fee as a part of considering the borrow pit application.
Supervisor Casteen requested that all environmentally sensitive areas
be listed on the Development Service District (DSD) maps. Following a
brief discussion, Supervisor Bradshaw suggested that the information be
shown on an overlay map to be included in the Comprehensive Plan.
3
//
Chairman Clark expressed the Board?s appreciation to the members of
the Planning Commission for their dedication, noting that the Board looks
forward to working with them in the future.
//
At 9:10 p.m., Supervisor Bradshaw moved that the Board adjourn its
meeting. The motion was adopted by a vote of (5-0) with Supervisors
Brown, Bradshaw, Clark, Casteen and Wright voting in favor of the motion,
and no Supervisors voting against the motion.
__________________________
Stan D. Clark, Chairman
______________________
Carey Mills Storm, Clerk
4
u~uureu~ `~Iz~i~ 'Q u~~S
__.~~
~izai~ ` ®~S si Y~i ~az~~
°uoi~ouz ar~~ ~sut~e~~ ~ui~on szosinxadnS ou pug
`uoi~ou~ aq} 3o zone ui ~ui~on ~u~izm pug uaa~s~~ `~z~i~ `mt~usp~zg `umozg
szosin.zadnS u~-m (p-s) ~o a;on ~ ~q pa~dop~ sum uor;ouz au1, •~ui~aaui
s~i uznofp~ pz~og a~~ ~~q; panoux mugsp~zg zos?^zadnS `•~°~ Oi~6 ;'~T
i0
•azn~rg aq~ ut u~a~~ u~-m ~ui~zom ox premza~
soot pz~og aye ~eu~ ~u-~ou `uoYzEarpap zrau~ zo,~ uoisstuxuzo~ ~uluueid aq~
~o szaquzauz aq~ o; uoi~~taazdde sapzEOg aq~ passazd~a ~z~i~ u~u~zt~u~