6/30/2016-Change Order #10 Benn's Church Intersection Improvement�, � Howard Brothers Contractor, Inc.
� P.O. Box 96
� � Providence Forge VA 23140
804-966-2762
License: 2701 039212A
To: County of Isle of Wight
P. O. Box 80
Isle of Wight VA 23397
Change O r
Order#: j1�1'�Ii
Order Date: 06/29/2016
Project: 1063
#15-4110-21 Benns Church
U PC#98244
VDOT #0010-046-R10,C501
PO#20160057-006
The contractor agrees to perform and the owner agrees to Plans Attached �
pay for the following changes to this contract.
Ordered By: 1 Samuel Howard Customer Order: 2016057-006 Specifications Attached ❑
Description of Work
Delay Costs
Notes
Re: NOIFC #1 and #2
Compensable Settlement as agreed
Negative changes will lower the overall contract
price requiring no additionat payment by owner.
Amount
•� ��� ��
Requested Amount of Change 90,000.00
Theoriginal Contract Sum was ...................................................................................................................................................................................... 4,225,263.55
Net change by previous Change Orders .......................................................................................................................................................... 160,660.33
The Contract Sum prior to this Change Order .................................................................................................................................... 4,385,923.88
The Contract Sum will be changed by this Change Order ................................................................................................... 90,000.00
The new Contract Sum including this Change Order will be ........................................................................................... 4,475,923.88
TheContract Time will be changed by .......................................................................................................,.................................................... 145 Days
Owner:
Contractor: �G%��2c�.� �• ����.�
Date: "� � � ( � � �
Date: 06/10/2016
� �
0
July 7, 2016
Isle of Wight County
Department of Public Works
P.O. Box 80
Isle of Wight, VA 23397
Attention: Ms. Jamie L. Oliver
Reference: Reconfiguration of Route 10/258 Intersection at Benns Church Blvd, UPC #98244
Change Order #9 Project Time Extension, Notice of Intent to File a Claim (NOIFC)
No. 1 and No. 2
Dear Ms. Oliver,
MBP has been providing construction engineering and inspection services for the above
mentioned project since the Notice To Proceed (NTP) on August 5, 2015. As such the County
requested that MBP review Howard Brothers Contractor Inc. (HBCI) request for a time
extension as represented in Change Order #9. HBCI requested compensation for 85 days of
delay due to NOIFC No. 1 and No. 2 in the amount of $90,000 in a letter written on May 12,
2016. The $90,000 change order consisted of $29,712.05 in standby equipment and $60,287.95
in home office overhead (HOOH). HBCI also requested a non-compensable time delay of 60
days in a letter dated lune 8, 2016. Both of these letters constitute Change Order #9.
The NOIFC No. 1 time delay started on August 5, 2015 due to clearing grubbing operations
being delayed because of an environmenta) Time of Year Restriction regarding the Northern
Long Ear Bat, an endangered species. This time delay ended on September 15, 2015 resulting in
a 41-day delay.
The NOIFC No. 2 time delay started on August 24, 2015 due to various utility conflicts
throughout the project. This time delay ended on October 29, 2015 when the stormwater
management basin outfall system had been redesigned. Thus resulting in a 66-day delay.
After review of both NOIFC time delays, it was concluded that the two NOIFCs overlapped by 22
days from August 24, 2015 through September 15, 2015, thus resulting in an 85-day total
compensable delay to the project. In addition to the review of both NOIFCs, MBP reviewed
HBCI's request for compensation for the 85-day delay. Based on the supporting documentation
that was submitted by H8C1, MBP recommends approval to compensate HBCI $90,000 for the
85-day project delay and recommends extending the contract duration by the same 85 days.
676 Independence Parkway, Suite 220 � Chesapeake, Virginia 23320 � 757-382-0109 - Tel ( 757-382-0147 - fax � www.mbpce.com
Jamie Oliver
July 7, 2016
Page 2
MBP along with the County also reviewed 60 days of non-compensable delay as outlined in
HBCI's June 8, 2016 letter that extended beyond October 29, 2015 and came to the following
conclusions:
1. The County and HBCI had concurrent delays that extended from October 29, 2015
through November 25, 2015 resulting in a 27-day delay.
2. Change Order #6 added 5 days to the contract.
3. Change Order #7 added 10 days to the contract.
4. Weather delays in April and May added 18 days to the contract.
In conclusion MBP recommends approval of Change Order #9 for a total time extension of 145
days with 85 days being compensable and 45 days being non-compensable.
Sincerely, �
o vf�
, Joseph V. Modica, PE
Project Manager
1VM
Attachments:
1. NOIFC #1
2. NOIFC #2
3. Change Order #6 C-10 Form
4. Change Order #7 C-10 Form
5. Change Order #9 C-10 Form
6. HBCI Letter Dated May 12, 2016
7. HBCI Letter Dated lune 8, 2016
MBP
676 lndependence Parkway, Suite 220 � Chesapeake, Virginia 23320 � 757-382-0109 - Tel � 757-382-0147 - fax � www.mbpce.com
//` �`// �
( ��
��
� � �
� ��
P.O. Box 96, Providence Forge Va. 23140
{604j%6-2�62
(804)9G6-92I4 - Fax
August 12, 2015
Isle of Wight County
Mr. Edwin Wrightson, Director of General Services
P. O. Box 80
Isle of Wight, VA 23397
Re: Intent to File Claim 001
IFB#15-4110-21
VDOT#010-046-R10, C501/UPC#98244
Dear Mr. Wrightson
Howard Brothers Contractor, Inc. received a project `Notice to Proceed" dated 7-31-15 and
requested a'`start of construction" date of 8-10-15.
On 8-5-15 we attended the project pre-construction conference. During the conference meeting
Ms. Jamie Oliver (Isle of Wight project engineer/manager) revealed that certain construction
activities would be delayed until after September 15`h or until the results of a habitat survey were
received and clearance given to begin construction activities in the study areas. Also, Ms. Oliver
explained that the waterline and associated utility components shown on the contract plan sheets
were being revised, and the revision documents would be forthcoming, presented to HBCI as a
change order revision.
As the mentioned delay, changes, and subsequent revisions affects the project construction
schedule we request the engineer review our position regarding the preconstruction comments.
Howard Brothers generated and presented our low bid quote and construction schedule based upon
multiple parameters, cost, time of year, duration of project and the detailed "sequence of
construction" matrix outlined on plan sheets 1 B thru 1 D(2). The previously mentioned construction
restrictions and utility plan changes directly impacts and alters our construction schedule. Example:
The clearing contractor was scheduled to begin project clearing on 8-10-15, this activity has been
delayed. Waterline utility work was scheduled to begin the week of August 10`�, this activity has
been rescheduled.
At this time we are re-scheduling sub-contractors, equipment, materials and work force, dedicated
to these affected activities to other construction phases on the project. Full impacts of the delay and
revision changes are not quantifiable at this time due to inconclusive direction regarding the
subject. We do not anticipate that the subject delays and utility revision changes will adversely
affect the project, and are moving forward with project construction.
Noticc of [ntent to File Claim 001
Page 2
Aug�st 12, 2015
In accordance with article 60 "Contractual Claims" of the contract documents, we hereby
respectably notify the Engineer that this is our notice of intent to file a claim for all time and cost
impacts incurred due to the delay/changes mentioned herein. Cost impacts may include, but not
be limited to, labor, equipment, materials, project overhead, and home office overhead. We may
also require an extension of time.
We will provide the Engineer with daily records during the period of impacts. We respectfully
request that you verify them to avoid dispute later. Currently the weather is favorable but the
delays could very well push operations into periods of more unfavorable inclement weather.
Once we have a better idea of when the delay will be lifted and utility changes defined, we can
provide the Engineer an estimate of costs and associated impacts.
If you have any questions please give me a call at 804-512-5878.
Sincerely
���
Samuel C. Howard
President
� �
{
����
.�
P.O. Box 9b, Provide�ce Forge Va. 23 I�0
(804)966-2762
(804)966-9214 - Fuc
August 25, 2015
Isle of Wight County
Jamie Oliver, Transportation Project Manager
P. O. Box 80
Isle of Wight, VA 23397
Re: Intent to File Claim #002
IFB#15-4110-21
VDOT#010-046-R10, CSO]/UPC#98244
Dear Ms. Oliver
Beginning August 10, 2015 we encountered and noted utilities in conflict with the proposed
project construction improvements. On August 18, 2015 our onsite staff began
keyhole/potholing of existing underground utilities in advance of the scheduled storm sewer
drainage system installation.
As of August 24, 2015 we have documented 29 utility conflicts on approximately 65% of the
project area, submitted 3 utility conflicts RFIs containing pertinent data on each noted conflict.
We have notified the engineer of this situation and asked for direction on how to proceed. At
this time we do not have definitive direction from the engineer.
The noted conflict delay greatly affects our construction schedule. Each critical phase of the
project is now on standby. Subcontractors have been placed on delay status, and our crews and
equipment dedicated to the project are now delegated to potholing utilities.
In an attempt to minimize the impact caused by this delay we are re-scheduling sub-contractors,
equipment, materials and work force, dedicated to the affected activities to other construction task.
Full impacts of the delay and revision changes are not quantifiable at this time due to inconclusive
direction regarding the subject. We do anticipate that, the subject delays and utility revision
changes will affect the project duration. We will continue to work with project staff to resolve the
issue as promptly as possible.
In accordance with article 60 "Contractual Claims" of the contract documents, we hereby
respectably notify the Engineer that this is our notice of intent to file a claim #002 for all time
and cost impacts incurred due to the utility delay/changes mentioned herein. Cost impacts may
include, but not be limited to, labor, equipment, materials, project overhead, and home office
overhead. We will also require an extension of time.
Notice of Intent to File Claim 02
Page 2
August 25, 2015
We will provide the Engineer with daily records during the period of impact. We respectfully
request that you verify them to avoid dispute later. Currently the weather is favorable but the
delays could very well push operations into periods of more unfavorable inclement weather.
Once the engineer has provided direction defining the utility conflict/changes, we can provide
the Engineer an estimate of costs and associated impacts.
If you have any questions please give me a call at 804-512-5878.
Sincerely
��� �
Samuel C. Howard
President
m
0
COMMONWEALTH OF VIRGINIA
DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION
WORK ORDER
F�t"Cil ��-1v
Re�;. 10-8-�7
Contract ID No.: UPC#98244 IFB#15-4i 10-21 FHWA No.: 534 No. 12003 Work Order No.: 6
State Project No.: 0017-036-R02 Cateyorv�
Original Contract Value $4,225.263.55 Total of Other Work Orders $50,720.70
NOTE: If additio�al space is needed, use an additional sheet(s) and label as Supplemental Attachment �k.
LOCATION AND DESCRIPTION OF PROPOSED WORK:
i his proposal is to fumish, instali, maintain and remove two Temporary Vehlcle Video Detection Cameras and Camera Control
Eq��ipment at the intersection of Route 10 and Route 258. This proposal aiso includes furnishing and irstalling a permanent
means of electrical disconnection for the new treffic signal controller ir, the median of the same intersection
RESPONSIBLE CHARGE ENGINEER'S EXPLANATION OF NECESSITY FOR PROPOSED WORK:
Tnis work order is for additiona! cos? due t� a Jirect request frrrn VDQT to maintain vehicie dciectien at the intersection of Route
10 and Route 258- Thi; w�rk order is needed to be d2�✓elopsd for the ad�iticnai work inciudirg labc�r, matersals. and e�uipment.
II1. FUNDING SOURCElCHARGE
IV. THE FIXED DATE TIME LIMIT FOR THIS CONTRACT PRIOR TO APPROVAL OF THIS WORK ORDER IS April i, 2016
V. THE FIXED DATE TIME LIMIT FOR THIS CONTRACT UPON APPROVAL OF THIS WORK ORDER IS April 1, 2016
VI. ESTIMATE OF PROPOSED WORK:
ITEM SPEC.
CODE NO.
C06-1 I NA
CO6-2 NA
ITEM DESCRIPTION
Dagan Electric Company Quote
Howard Brothers Markup (10%)
QUANTITY ( UNIT � UNIT PRICE I INCREASE I DECREASE
NET TOTAL
1 LS $14,477.62 $14,477.62
1 LS $1,447.76 $1,447.76
$0
IMIE hereby agree to perform and/or non-perform as indicated, the work described herein and at the unit prices set foRh and that
such work shail be performed in accordance with the contract provisions and specifications and/or other provisions incorporated
herein. Further IIWE hereby agree that the quantities set foRh herein will be subject to adjustment and, unless otherwise stated, the
unit prices set forth herein will be applicable to the adjusted quantities.
Contractor gy
(Firm's Name) (Officer of the Firm)
RECOMMENDED FOR APPROVAL:
lf � f /4 � ra /,--,�
��,��, l� l � l�
� �
ECOMMENDED BY TITLE D E
(MBP}
RECOMMENDED BY TITLE DATE
(isle of Wight County)
Form C-10
°e�i. 1 a-8-07
APPROVED:
APPROVED BY• (VDOT)
Contract ID. No.:
State Project No.:
TITLE DATE
APPROVED:
APPROVED BY (FHWA) DATE
COMMONWEALTH OF VIRGINIA
DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION
WORK ORDER
Supplemental Attachment #
FHWA No.:
Work Order No.:
� � Howard Brothers Contractor, Inc.
P.O. Box 96
� Providence Forge VA 23140
�� � 804-966-2762
License: 2701 039212A
To: County of Isle of Wight
P. O. Box 80
Isle of Wight VA 23397
The contractor agrees to perform and the owner agrees to
pay for the following changes to this contract.
Ordered By: 1 Samuel Howard Customer Order:
Description of Work
Change Order
Order#: 6
Order Date: 12/10/2015
Project: 1063
#15-4110-21 Benns Church
U PC#98244
VDOT #0010-046-R10,C501
Plans Attached �
Specifications Attached ❑
Survey/Layoff
Conflict MH (5)
CO Qty for (5) paid by LF @$986.00 (approximately) unit price for overrun Conflict MH's
ST-4 Approx 50' @20.90 per ft
1/2"x2'x10' 60 duro neoprene
VDOT Flow Fill (fly ash)
CO Qty for (3.5 CY) paid by CY @$303.59 (approximately) Unit Price for Overrun on VDOT Flow Fill
(fly ash)
Notes
Conflict manhole and drainage components associated with the storm drainage revision plan sheet # 8 and
#9 dated 10-29-15.
Scope of work:
- Provide survey /layoff of revised storm drainage plan
- Construct (5) conflict manholes as per plan revision. JBC entails construction of MH, F/C and related
components only /HBCI scope of work per conflict MH: (Unit price inclued with CO for overruns)
Excavation, shoring, de-watering, stone base, installation of utility encasement sleeve,
Amount
2,200.00
22,775.00
1, 045.00
1, 028.60
1, 062.56
Negative changes will lower the overall contract
price requiring no additional payment by owner. ReqUeSted A1110Uf1t Of Chellge 28,111.16
Theoriginal Contract Sum was ...................................................................................................................................................................................... 4,225,263.55
Net change by previous Change Orders .......................................................................................................................................................... 77,647.58
The Contract Sum prior to this Change Order ..................................................................................................................................... 4,302,911.13
The Contract Sum will be changed by this Change Order ................................................................................................... 28,111.16
The new Contract Sum including this Change Order will be ........................................................................................... 4,331,022.29
TheContract Time will be changed by ............................................................................................................................................................. 5 Days
Owner: Date:
Contractor: �G�h�� C� 9Y��u�Cvi.� Date: 12/10/2015
Change Order
Continued...
Order: 6
Date: 12/10/2015
Description of Work Amount
coordination backfill
- Abandon approx.. 46' x 18" existing cross pipe sta. 23+25 EBL Brewers Neck Blvd... VDOT flowable fill
(fly ash) (Unit price included with CO for overruns)
- Install (2) utility separation/cushioning pads sta. 23+25 WBL and sta. 26+00 EBL Brewers Neck Bivd.
'CO from Proposal submitted on 12/01/2015
Page 2 of 2
Form C-10
Rev. 14-8-07
COMMONWEALTH OF VIRGINIA
DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION
WORK ORDER
Contract ID No.: UPC#98244 IFB#15-4110-21 FHWA No.: 534 No. 12003 Work Order No.: 6
State Project No.: 0017-036-R02 Categorv:
Original Contract Value $4,225263.55 Total of Other Work Orders $50,720.70
NOTE: If additional space is needed, use an additional sheet(s) and label as Supplemental Attachment #.
I. LOCATION AND DESCRIPTION OF PROPOSED WORK:
�� s�.,r,�posal is tu f� �sh, ir�sta��. mair�iain an� rFmove hr�o Temporary Vehicle Video DeCection Cameras as�d Camera Gontrol
�.; ,'pment at the intersection of Route 10 and Route 258. This proposal also inciudes furnishing and installing a permanent
rneans of electrical disconnection for the new traffic signai controller in the median af the same intersection.
II. RESPONSIBLE CHARGE ENGINEER'S EXPLANATION OF NECESSITY FOR PROPOSED WORK:
'���is work ordvr I�'� a��.a�t rai cost ��e to a dir; ct r�.,�ues' `!en� VC�O� tu � a;nta�r v�h.c e detecti�n at the irYerseciion of Route
�?�rid Raut2 2�8. Thls w�;k o.d�r is nee�eci to be a��vel��p�c± f�r +.he a��ii`ional :cork in !!d�.�g r��or. material.�_ and eq�!iprnent.
III. FUNDING SOURCE/CHARGE
IV. THE FIXED DATE TIME LIMIT FOR THIS CONTRACT PRIOR TO APPROVAL OF THIS WORK ORDER IS April t 2016
V. THE FIXED DATE TIME LIMIT FOR THIS CONTRACT UPON APPROVAL OF THIS WORK ORDER IS April 1, 2016
VI. ESTIMATE OF PROPOSED WORK:
ITEM SPEC
CODE NO.
C06-1 NA
C06-2 NA
ITEM DESCRIPTION
Dagan Electric Company Quote
Howard Brothers Markup (10%)
QUANTITY I UNIT I UNIT PRICE I INCREASE I DECREASE
1 LS
1 LS
NET Increase/Decrease
NET TOTAL
$14,477.62 $14,477.62 $0
$1,447.76 $1,447.76
$15,925.38 $0
$15,925.38 $0
I/WE hereby agree to perform and/or non-perform as indicated, the work described herein and at the unit prices set forth and that
such work shall be performed in accordance with the contract provisions and specifications and/or other provisions incorporated
herein. Further I/WE hereby agree that the quantities set forth herein will be subject to adjustment and, unless otherwise stated, the
unit prices set forth herein will be applicable to the adjusted quantities.
Contractor BY
(Firm's Name) (Officer of the Firm)
RECOMMENDED FOR APPROVAL:
RECOMMENDED BY TITLE DATE RECOMMENDED BY TITLE DATE
(�v1Pc�i (IsIE' Gf'w^JiPi??" CoEir}iyj
� � Howard Brothers Contractor, Inc.
P.O. Box 96
r� P Providence Forge VA 23140
� � 804-966-2762
License: 2701 039212A
To: County of Isle of Wight
P. O. Box 80
Isle of Wight VA 23397
Change Order
Order#: 7
Order Date: 12/10/2015
Project: 1063
#15-4110-21 Benns Church
U PC#98244
VDOT #0010-046-R10,C501
The contractor agrees to perform and the owner agrees to Plans Attached �
pay for the following changes to this contract.
Ordered By: 1 Samuel Howard Customer Order: Specifications Attached ❑
Description of Work
#57 Stone/Ton
VDOT Item#27552 Spec#308
CO is Based on Approximately 325 Tons @$72.88 Per Ton (Unit Price to be used for Overruns)
#3 Stone/Ton
VDOT Item#10250 Spec#308
CO is Based on Approximately 325 Tons @$55.58 Per Ton (Unit Price to be used for Overruns)
U D-4/LF
VDOT Item#00588 Spec#501
CO is Based on Approximately 300LF @$17.25 Per LF (Unit Price to be used for Overruns)
Notes
Change Order per proposal submitted on 11/10/2015 for the purchase and installation of approx..
- 325 tons of #57 stone aggregate as a drainage /stabilization course required due to an unsuitable pipe
trench foundation
- 325 tons of #3 stone aggregate as a subgrade stabilization course.
-300 LF of VDOT std. UD-4
As noted on Each Item Totals are calculated on Estimated Qtys. shown. This is to add pay items to
Negative changes will lower the overall contract
price requiring no additional payment by owner. R@qU2St@d AIT10UIlt Of Ch811g@
The original Contract Sum was .....................................................................................
Net change by previous Change Orders ........................................................
The Contract Sum prior to this Change Order ....................................
The Contract Sum will be changed by this Change Order ..
The new Contract Sum including this Change Order will be
The Contract Time will be changed by .............................................................
Owner: Date:
Contractor: �G:,h�.� e�u-�t.c� Date: 12/10/2015
Amount
23,686.00
18, 063.50
5,175.00
46,924.50
........................ 4,225,263.55
.......................... 77,647.58
......................... 4, 302, 911.13
........................ 46, 924.50
4,349,835.63
10 Days
Change Order
Continued...
Description of Work
contract with a unit price as given here in.
Page 2 of 2
Order: 7
Date: 12/10/2015
Amount
I�
Form C-i0
Re<<_ � 0-�3-07
COMMONWEALTH OF VIRGINIA
DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION
WORK ORDER
Contract ID No.: UPC#98244 IFB#15-4110-21 FHWA No.: 534 No. 12003 Work Order No.: 07
State Project No.: 0017-036-R02 Categorv�
Original Contract Value �,225,263.55 Total of Other Work Orders $50.720J0
NOTE: It additional space is needed, use an additional sheet(s) and label as Supplemental Attachment #.
LOCATION AND DESCRIPTION OF PROPOSED WORK:
A!ter clearing ar��d grubbing �r,as completed !or th� area cf tne proposed Brewer's Neck Extension road unexpected differing site
conditions were observed. it �roas discovered that there is a high water table and running ground water at the head of the existing
ditches. Since the ground water is not a point source, the Engineer has designed a French Drain that will direct the ground water
under the proposed road and to the ditch. It is recommended inat the perforated French Drain pipe be encased in fil;er fabric
and ?8" x 18" of �57 stone and al' proposed storm drain pipes in this area of the project (including structures) be bedded with at
least 6' of k57 stone. It is aiso antir,ipater that =3 s'ore vvi,l be r,eeccd to assist in stabilizing some we( areas of the proposed
road bed.
RESPONSIBLE CHARGE ENGINEER'S EXPLANATION OF NECESSITY FOR PROPOSED WORK:
!n crdcr to estabiish and maintain suitable subgraae mater�,al and not unclermin� the integriry of the road in the future the
underdrain system needs to �e installed. In adherence to VDOT specifications N57 stone will he required if and when storm pipe
is installed in we! conditions. The �!57 stone wili be capped as required The #3 stone will be utilized if required in areas where
add�tional stabilizaticn fs needed.
III. FUNDING SOURCE/CHARGE
IV. THE FIXED DATE TIME UMIT FOR THIS CONTRACT PRIOR TO APPROVAL OF THIS WORK ORDER IS April 1; 2C16
V. THE FIXED DATE TIME LIMIT FOR THIS CONTRACT UPON APPROVAL OF THIS WORK ORDER IS April t, 2p16
VI. ESTIMATE OF PROPOSED WORK:
ITEM SPEC. ITEM DESCRIPTION QUANTITY UNIT UNIT PRICE INCREASE DECREASE
CODE NO.
C07-1 I I#57 Stone Aggregate Pipe Bedding 325 I TN $72.88 $23,686.00 $0
C07-2 5TR 5-2 DI-2B 325 TN $55.58 $18,063.50 $0
C07-3 PG-2A TY E 300 LF $17.25 $5,175.00 $0
rease
INVE hereby agree to perform and/or non-perform as indicated, the work described herein and at the unit prices set forth and that
such work shall be pertortned in accordance with the contract provisions and specifications and/or other provisions incorporated
herein. Further I/WE hereby agree that the quantities set forth herein will be subject to adjustment and, unless otherwise stated, the
unit prices set forth herein will be applicable to the adjusted quantities.
Contractor gY
(Firm's Name) (Officer of the Firm)
Form G10
Rev. 10-8-07
RECOMMENDEDFOR APPROVAL:
� � � �j r
� � �`
�� � �
r a �" � 1
; �'L{ .��; f,
i%'�RECOMMENDED BY TITLE D TE RECOMMENDED BY TITLE DATE
(IV1BP) {Isle of Wight County)
APPROVED:
APPROVED BY' (VDOT)
Contract ID. No.:
State Project No.:
TITLE DATE
APPROVED:
APPROVED BY (FHWA) DATE
COMMONWEALTH OF VIRGINIA
DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION
WORK ORDER
Supplementa! Attachment #
FHWA No.:
Work Order No.:
Contract ID Nc.: �P�B-a
State Project Na oc;o�oas-�io csci
COMMONWEALTH OF VIRGINIA
DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION
WORK ORDER
FHWA No 53a No. t2003
Form G10
Rev t0.8-07
Work Order No.: 9
�.aic ui
Onginal Contract Value 5 a.n52535s Totai of Other Work Ortlers $ 160.660.33
NOTE: If additional space is needetl, use an add�tional sheet(s) and label as Supplemental Attachment #.
I. LOCATION AND DESCRlPTION OF PROPOS�D WORK:
During the construction of this project (Isle of Wight County at Rte 258/10) there have been a number of
delays and utility conflicts which have resulted in a cost to the contractor.
II. RF_SPONSIBLE CH�,RGE FN�WEER'S EXPLANATION OF NECESSITY FOR PROPOSED WORK.
IIL FUNDING SOURCE/CHARGE
IY. THE FIXED DATE TIME LIMIT FOR THIS CONTRACT PRIOR TO APPRVOAL OF THtS WORK ORDER IS z40
V. THE FIXED DATE TIME LIMIT FOR THIS CONTRACT UPON APPROVAL OF THIS WORK ORDER IS 385
VI. ESTIMATE OF PROPOSED WORK:
ITEM SPEC. ITEM UNIT
CODE NO. DESCRIPTION QUANTITY UNIT PRICE INCREASE DI
Delay Costs 1 l5 90,000.00 90,OOQAO
NET TOTAL
sa.000 oa
eo oao 00
E
1MlE hereby agree to pertorm andlor non-perFOrm as indicated, the work described herein and at the unit prices set forth and that such
work shall be periormed in accordance with the contract provis�ons and specifications and/or other provisions incorporated herein.
Further IM/E hereby agree that the quantities set forth herein will be subject to adjustment and, uniess otherwise stated, the unit pp�es
set forth herein will be applicabie to the adjusted quantities. /i
Contracior Howard Brothers Conlractor Inc. ,g� / //
(F�rtn's NameJ (Officer of the Firm) ate
RECOMMENOED FOR APPROVAL:
V� � � 6
RECOMMENDEp BY TITLE DATE RECOMMEN ED BY TITLE ATE
�oseP� �� Nv1o�6`���
APPROVED:
APPROVED BY' (VDO� TITLE DATE
' See CD-2006-02 for Process and Authorities
APPROVED:
APPROVED BY (FHWA} DATE
ly���
owar
�o e�s
on �ac o�
l�nc.
Reconfiguration of Route 10/2�8 Intersection at I3enns Church Bl��d
Isle of Wight County, Virginia
VDOT State Project No. 0010-0�6-R10,C_501
UPC#9824d
FHWA No. 53�3 \o. 12003
IFB#15-4110-21 Dela�� Costs
�
\
Brurhers
/
Cvritrttctor
� In�. �
Nia}� 13. 2016
lsle oi Wi�_ht Count�. Vir��inia
Jamie Oliver. Project Mana��er
POBo�c80
l.le of Wi�ht. VA 23397
(SLE OF WIGNT IFB n15-4110-21
VDOT Project 0010-0d6-R10, Ci01/UPCn98244!lsle of lVight County
F ��r'HA 53�1 No. 12003
Subiect �OITFC (?) O��ners Reqiie;t �f Co;tS tn Uat�
Dear �9s. Oli�er.
Pursuant to ARicle 60 Contractual Claims of the Contract Documents for ReconfiQuration of Route 10;258
lnter�cction at Benns Church Boulevard, Ho��ard Brothers Contractor, lnc. ("Howard Brothers") has submitted (2)
NOIZ�FC. The O�vner (IOW) has requested a cost attached to these claims.
Che amount sought is 590,000.00. (Supporting documents enclosed)
Durin� the construction of this praject there have been a number of delays and utilit} conflicts which have resulted
in a cost to the contractor. Please revie« this summary of claim events and time line.
ln summary:
The (2) NOIFC events resulted in 8� days of delay and out of sequence construction that directl} impacted the
critical path �f the project. Clearin�� of the site due to bat restrictions delayed HBI from excavatin�� the storm ��ater
mana�ement basin (SWMB). "This near critical activiry became critical wh�n the site could not be cleared on time
accordin� to the attached baseline CPM schedule. The more direct impact to the critical path occurred due to
conflicts �vith the SI��MB ouCfall drainaQe rystem. Multiple critical path iYems could not be started or completed as
can be seen on the attached baseline schedule. These activities inclucied Sa�v Cut:lnstall x-pipes — Bre��ers Neck
Blvd, Bre�vers Neck str 8-9 thru 8-12. and SN'MB excavatiomConstruction. The SWMB could not be constructed
��ithout an outfall s}�stem and the draina�,e system for the new� extension road also could not be constructed. These
issues ��ere not resolved until October 39, 2015 �1hen Kimley-Horn finalized the redesi<�n of the SWMB outfall
draina�e s}stem. These delays resulted in: Multiple re-mobilizations to facilitate construction pro��ress and
dedicated equipment piaced on standb}. HBC personnel scheduled for this project redirected to other projects with
resu(tant overhead cost to those projects. Additional cost due to time of year with resultant delays, working hours
and ���et weather conditions.
Ho�card E3rother• b�li����s e��ery� efturt ha� been ma�le by thz Contractor to keep th� project mo�in�� tor���ard. bein�,
proactive in initiating questions, makin� su,��estions, providing Engineer data to expedite desi�n and «orkin�
closely �vith the Q'A. Q-C personnel to minimize construction cost. �
As a result of the noted dela}s and contlicts. �e respectfully request revie�v of documents ar.d subsequent payment
for costs incurred.
Sincerely
� . �.. /? ��'
�� ���j� �./
��16f�42�� wi� .c��i+ s�i� �:'
Samuel C. Ho�� ard, President
Attachments Factual timeline, Cost Summarv
Cc: Joseph F1. Ka�imer. l:sq. Kasimer. Pierce & Schecher PC
Dated Factual Timeline
The follo�vin� timeline presents the situation that occurred:
• August �, 2015 — Howard Brothers ��as notitied at preconstruction confer�nce of specific
construction aetivities being delayed d�ie to species habitat environment being active
09/15/201 �. Also the discussion of revised plan sheets being produced for w�aterline and
utility components to be presented to Howard Brothers as a change order.
• August 12, 2015 — Ho���ard f3rothers submitted "Intent to File Claim" �ti�ith Isle of Wight
Count�� on Species Delav and Waterline Utility Plan Revisions Delay.
• August 18, 2015 — Ho�vard Brothers submitted RFI#� addressing utility conflicts durina
potholing in advance of schedulcd stonn pipe and structurc installations.
• August 20, 201 �— Ho�card Brotl�et•s submitted RFI#� addressin;; additional utilit5�
conflicts during potholing in advance of scheduled storm pipe and structure installations.
• August 21, 2015 — Howard Brothers submitted RF1#6 addressing additional utility
conflicts during potholing in advance of construction. Submitted ���ith detailed stations
and locations.
• August 2�, 2015 — Ho�vard Brothers submitted "lntent to File Claitn" ���ith Isle of W'ight
County= on C�tility Conflicts.
• August 28, 2015 —�Io��ard �3rothers submitted RFI#7 sho�ing exploratory potholing of
potential underbround utilit�� conflicts over a(5) day period 8/24-8/28. A request was
made in an effort to reduce further impact to the construction schedule. resulting in
dclays and potential cost Ho���ard Bt•others requested Engineer direction regardin� these
conflicts.
• September 15. 2015 — Installation of storm pipe #4-2 to #�-3 stopped due to inadequate
pipc: cocer. Remobilization of cre��.
• October �, 2015 — Howard Brothers submitted email to IOW w�ith costs incurred for
potholin�� utilitti� conflicts. (�l)
• Oetober 23, 2015 — Howard Brotheis submitted RFI#14 fiber optic in conflict of
roadwaS�. Remobilization of cre��.
• October 29, 201� — Pond Outtall Re��ision I-�inaliz�d
Modified Eichlea� Formula
• Tota] Delay Period Aug 5 201 �— Nov 24. 2015 (112 Days) 27 llays Non-
Compensatory
• Actual Billings for Project during delay period -$988,3�6.�4
• Earnings Schedule Baseline projected -�1,440,907.29 (Form G13C)
• Billings short per base line projection -$�52.5�0.7�
• Allowable HOOH for Delay Period ($292,$ ll.24)
$452,550.75 =.295� Ratio X$292,811.24 (HOOH durin= dela� period)
$1,531,330.74 Company Biliings during delay period (onl� 2 active contracts �uh- \o�)
292,811?4 X 29�5= 586,�2�.72/122Days=709.27 Per Day�
(\ote the 122 Da��s is the calendar days Aug 1—:�iov 30 to get daily HOOH Daily Rate)
S709.27 Y 8� Da��s Dela� = SG0,287.9�
Costs incurred due to Dela��
Standby Equipment
Ucia� Equipm��:! >tan datc ��a. tl8 1 l l�— t�1 29 2111 j
Eichleay HOOII
Total Costs Calculated
� �9.%1?.�J (time / Dail� Vl'ork Report� and submittcd dailv)
� 60,287.95 (see fornlula above)
590,000.00
*Multiple renrobilizations on project creatir�g �lelays of 3 to 4 hocrrs per move, orrt of sequence
co�rstrrrctio�t creatifig arr increased o/!t oir project (�toted i�r Daily Work reports)
*HBCI reserves tl:e right to add costs for refnobilization, extended supervision and freld
overhead and loss of productivity ij'we cannot get this resolved in a prompt at:d fair manner.
12 2005 Mack Dump - Granite CV713
13 2006 Mack Dump - Granite CV713
3 1995 Ford 9000 LT� Rd Tractor
2 1989 Int'I 51700 crash cushion
48 15 Lt Amida Arrowboard - 55 wt
91 2015 15 Light Wanco ArrowBoard
63 1997 Freightliner FL70 H20 trk
33 2001 Eager Beaver 50 GSL
39 1995 Borco Dump Trailer
18 1997 CAT 3226L Excavator/1-8yd
19 2002 CAT 320C LU Excavator
97 CAT 308 Excavator
16 2000 CAT 924G Loader
29 2006 CAT 924G Wheel Loader
15 1999 CAT DSC Dozer
23 2005 John Deere 700H Dozer
34 2002 Dynapac Roller CA 250
37 Wacker RT Roller Sheepsfoot
30 2007 John Deere 50D Excavator
Stand by Equipment
August 5 - Oct 29
L009
L013
LO10
L016
A004
A007
L021
T-600
T500
E800
E903
RE-22
E902
E914
E901
E909
E913
E916
E915
Stand by rates based on Blue Book Rates
and calculated per VDOT specs.
50 percent of rate for equipment
less operating cost.
Hours
142
48
231
108
135.5
308
0
10
239
309
134
48
13
205.5
185
117
307
315
15
Standby Rate
$10.33
$10.33
$9.15
$4.98
$0.84
$0.84
$6.39
$5.54
$2.95
$22.14
$22.31
$14.56
$9.69
$9.69
$12.84
$16.11
$12.74
$9.62
$7.75
$1,466.86
$495.84
$2,113.65
$537.84
$113.82
$258.72
$0.00
$55.40
$705.05
$6,841.26
$2,989.54
$698.88
$125.97
$1,991.30
$2,375.40
$1,884.87
$3,911.18
$3,030.30
$116.17
$29,712.05
/ rvr.;
r
ouard
Brothers
/
Contrac,tor
\ Inc. �
June 8, 2016
Isle of Vl-'ight County, Virginia
Jamie Oliver, Project Manager
P O Box 80
Isle of Wight, VA 23397
ISLE OF WIGHT IFB #15-4110-21
VDOT Project 0010-0-�6-R10, C501/UPC#98244/Isle of Wight County
FWHA 534 No. 12003
Subject: Time Extension
Dear Ms. Oliver,
During the construction of this project there have been a number of delays and utility conflicts which resulted in (2)
N.O.I.F.C. letters with a cost of time and money to the contractoc The compensatory settlement regarding the noted
delays has been reconciled between Howard Brothers and Isle of Wight. However, there are continuing non-
compensatory delays related to ongoing conflicts, change orders, plan revisions and weather which need to be
factored in project duration.
The (2) N.O.LF.C. delays resulted in a delay period of 1 12 days beyond the April 1, 2016 FCD, of these, 85 days
were consider as being compensatory and satisfied as noted above. Change order #6 added 5 days to the contract and
Change order #7 (while not performed per design was executed by field revision to accomplish the same) added 10
additional days to the contract. The number of days as shown tallies 127 with a completion date being 8-5-2016.
Record wet weather on the project in April/May and ongoing plan revisions resulted in an additional loss of 18 work
days. HBCI respectfully requests a time extension of 145 Days with completion date being 08/23/2016.
HBC[ and IOW have worked together to keep this project productive and positive and are striving for a quality
project. For all parties involved this extension will provide for such a product.
Please review, comment and approve.
Respectfully,
� � /
Samuel C. Howard
President
File:UPC#98244 Time Extension Request