Loading...
6/14/2016 Tax Status Maintenance AgreementTAX STATUS MAINTENANCE AGREEMENT (WESTERN BRANCH PIPELINE) THIS TAX STATUS MAINTENANCE AGREEMENT (this "Agreement") is made effective this 14th day of June , 2016, by and between the WESTERN TIDEWATER WATER AUTHORITY (the "Authority") and the CITY OF SUFFOLK, VIRGINIA (the "City"), which is a member jurisdiction of the Authority, and joined by the COUNTY OF ISLE OF WIGHT, VIRGINIA (the "County"), which is a member jurisdiction of the Authority (each a"Party" and collectively the "Parties"). RECITALS A. Unless otherwise defined, each capitalized term used herein shall have the meaning given it in the Western Branch Pipeline Transfer Agreement of even date herewith (the "Transfer Agreement") between the Authority and the City and joined into by the County. B. The Transfer Agreement provides, among other things, for the transfer from the City to the Authority of the Western Branch Pipeline and related real and personal property more particularly defined as the "Project." C. Pursuant to Section 8 of the Transfer Agreement, the City has requested the Authority and the County to enter into this Agreement to acknowledge the sources of financing of the Project and to agree to take, or refrain from taking, certain actions to preserve the tax status of such financing. D. A copy of the executed Transfer Agreement is attached hereto as Exhibit A. AGREEMENT NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration of the foregoing and other good and valuable consideration, the Parties hereby agree as follows: Section 1. Acknowleqement. The Authority and the County hereby acknowledge that the City (i) financed the acquisition, construction and equipping of the various components of the Project in whole or in part with the proceeds of tax-exempt governmental bonds and "Build America Bonds" issued by the City or by the Virginia Resources Authority for the City's benefit (collectively with any bonds or other obligations issued to refund such bonds, the "City Bonds"), and (ii) Sections 103, 141-150, 54AA and 6431 of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as amended(the "Tax Code"), and the applicable regulations and rulings contain numerous provisions with which the City must comply in order to maintain the federal income tax status of the City Bonds. Such compliance is 7758A3363 required by the financing documents the City has entered into with the Virginia Resources Authority and for the benefit of the other holders of the City Bonds. Section 2. General. The Authority agrees that it will not take any action with respect to the Project, or omit to take any action with respect to the Project, if any such action or omission would adversely affect the federal income tax status of the City Bonds under the Tax Code. Section 3. Private Business Use Restrictions. (a) In addition to the general covenant set forth in Section 2 above, the Authority agrees that, unless the Authority obtains the opinion described in subsection (c) below, the Authority will not enter into any arrangement or otherwise permit all or any portion of the Project to be actually or beneficially used directly or indirectly in the Trade or Business of a Nongovernmental Person within the meaning of Treasury Regulations Section 1.141-1(a). Without limiting the foregoing, examples of proscribed arrangements include the following: (1) A sale or transfer of ownership of all or any portion of the Project to a Nongovernmental Person; (2) A lease of all or any portion of the Project to a Nongovernmental Person; (3) Use of all or any portion of the Project by a Nongovernmental Person pursuant to a Management Contract, other than an Exempt Management Contract or a Qualified Management Contract; and (4) Use of all or any portion of the Project by a Nongovernmental Person under any other arrangement that conveys special legal entitlements that are comparable to those of an owner, lessee or manager, including take-or-pay or output-type arrangements and arrangements that convey priority rights to the use or capacity of the Project or the system of which the Project is a part. (b) Each of the following capitalized terms used in this Section 3 shall have the meaning given it below: (1) "Exempt Management Contract" means a contract with a Nongovernmental Person that would otherwise be a Management Contract for services with respect to the Project (i) that are solely incidental to the primary governmental function or functions of the Project (for example, contracts for janitorial, office equipment repair, billing, or similar services) or (ii) if the only compensation is the reimbursement of the Nongovernmental Person for actual and direct expenses paid by the Nongovernmental Person to unrelated parties. -2- (2) "Management Contract" means a contract under which a Nongovernmental Person will provide services involving all, a portion or any function of the Project. For example, a Management Contract includes a contract for the provision of management services for all or any portion of the Project or the system of which the Project is a part. (3) "Nongovernmental Person" means any natural person, firm, joint venture, association, partnership, business trust, corporation or any other entity (including the federal government and any of its agencies and instrumentalities) that is not a state or local governmental unit within the meaning of Section 141 of the Tax Code. (4) "Qualified Management Contract" means a Management Contract that complies with the term and compensation limitations and the other provisions of Revenue Procedure 97-13, 1997-1 C.B. 632, as modified by Revenue Procedure 2001-39, 2001-28 I.R.B. 38, and Notice 2014-67, 2014-46 I.R.B. 822. A summary of the Revenue Procedures and the Notice is attached hereto as Exhibit B. (5) "Trade or Business" shall have the meaning set forth in Section 141(b)(6)(B) of the Tax Code, and includes, with respect to any Nongovernmental Person other than a natural person, any activity carried on by such Nongovernmental Person. (c) Notwithstanding any provisions of this Section, if the Authority provides to the City an opinion of McGuireWoods LLP or another nationally- recognized bond counsel reasonably satisfactory to the City to the effect that compliance with any provision set forth in this Section or in any other Section of this Agreement is not or is no longer required to maintain the federal income tax status of the City Bonds under the Tax Code, the Authority shall not be required to comply with the provision. Section 4. Term of Aqreement. The Authority's obligations under this Agreement shall remain in effect so long as any of the City Bonds remains unpaid (whether or not defeased). Section 5. Access to Proiect and Information. The City and its duly authorized representatives and agents shall have such reasonable rights of access to the Project as may be necessary to determine whether the Authority is in compliance with the requirements of this Agreement and shall have the right at all reasonable times and upon reasonable prior notice to the Authority to examine and copy the Authority's books and records insofar as such books and records relate to the Project and the provisions of this Agreement. Section 6. Exhibits. All exhibits attached hereto shall be deemed to be an integral part of this Agreement. -3- Section 7. Further Assurances. Each Party shall execute and deliver such other instruments or documents and take such other actions, whether prior or subsequent to the Closing, as may be reasonably requested by another Party to consummate more effectively the purposes or subject matter of this Agreement. Section 8. Assiqnment. This Agreement may not be assigned by any Party without the prior written consent of all other Parties. Section 9. Interpretation. This Agreement shall be construed in accordance with and governed for all purposes by the laws of the Commonwealth of Virginia and shall be interpreted as if it were mutually drafted by the Parties. Section 10. Severabilitv. Should any provision of this Agreement be held to be invalid, illegal or unenforceable by a court of competent jurisdiction, that fact shall not affect or invalidate any other provisions, which shall remain in full force and effect. It is the intent of the Parties that in lieu of any provision of this Agreement that is illegal, invalid or unenforceable, the parties in good faith shall supply as part of this Agreement a legal, valid and enforceable provision as similar to such illegal, invalid or unenforceable provision as may be possible. Section 11. Inteqration. This Agreement contains all commitments and agreements of the Parties with respect to the subject matter of this Agreement and no verbal or written commitments other than this Agreement shall have any force or effect regarding the subject matter hereof. Section 12. Counterparts. This Agreement may be executed in two or more counterparts, each of which shall be deemed an original, but all of which together shall constitute one and the same instrument. A facsimile or scanned signature may substitute for and have the same legal effect as an original signature, and any copy of this executed Agreement made by photocopy, facsimile or scanner shall be considered the original. Section 13. Isle of Wiqht Approval. The County joins in this Agreement solely for the purpose of evidencing its consent to the terms hereof. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the Western Tidewater Authority, the City of Suffolk and the County of Isle of Wight have caused this Agreement to be signed in their names and on their behalf by the Chairman of the Board of Directors, the City Manager and the County Administrator, respectively. [SIGNATURES BEGIN ON FOLLOWING PAGE] -4- WES � ATTEST: ���� Albert S. Moor, II Secretary TIDEWA ER WATER AUTHORITY , � �� ' ichael D. Duman airman of the Board of Directors [SIGNATURES CONTINUE ON FOLLOWING PAGE] -5- ATti�EST: CITY OF SUFFOLK, VIRGINIA � __ _ _ _. ____ _ B � � � � ��-�- �� y� Patrick Roberts City Manager , `'� �,i�,���, �Erika S. Dawley /1 City Clerk �� APPROVED AS TO FORM: � Helivi L. Holland City Attorney [SIGNATURES CONTINUE ON FOLLOWING PAGE] � COUNTY OF ISLE OF WIGHT �� J I BY� � - Sanford B. Wanner Interim County Administrator ATTEST: �i�rm� Care ills S rm County Clerk APPROVE AS TO FORM: Mark C. P ovich County Attorney -7- TAX STATUS MAINTENANCE AGREEMENT (WESTERN BRANCH PIPELINE) LIST OF EXHIBITS Exhibit A — Transfer Agreement Exhibit B. — Summary of Revenue Procedures 97-13 and 2001-39 and Notice 2014-67 : PLACEHOLDER FOR EXECUTED TRANSFER AGREEMENT E�ibit B RF.STRICTIONS ON MANAGEVIE\'T AND OTHER SERVICE CONTRACTS Any State or local governinental unit (a "governmental entity") that takes advantage of tax-exempt bond financing agrees to take or refrain from taking such actions as may he necessary to preserve the status of the bonds as ta�-exempt governnzental bonds. If the bonds ���cre to lose tlicir tax-exempt stahis, i� is likely that ihe gavernmental entity �vou�d be subject to increased debt service costs under "make-whole" provisioils in the bonds ar lawsuits #rom angry bond�olders (�vho may o�ve back taYes on the interest they have received) o�- both. Qne of the basic requirements for the maintenanc� of the tax-exempt status of �ovcrnmental bonds is to prevent the bonds from becaming "private activity bonds" under Section 141(a) of the I��ternal Revenue Code of 1986, as ame�nded (the "Code"). Avoidance ot private activity bond status generally requires compliance with strict limits on any private 6usiness use of the bond-tinanced property. Section 141{b)(6} of the Codc defizles "privatc busincss use" as use (directly or indirectly) of bond-fu�anced property in a trade or business ca�-ried on by a nongoverninenial entity. For this purpose, a"nongovenunental entity" means any nariiral person, firm, joint venture, association, partnership, business trust, corporation, limitcd liability� company, corporation, or any other entity (including a federal, state or local �overnmental entity) other than a governmental entity, The United States and any agencies and instri�mentalities thereof are not governtnernal entities under this definition. Section 1.141-3(b}(1} provides that both actual and beneficial use of bond-financed property by a nongovernmental entity may be treated as private business use. In most cases, the private business use test is met only il a nonboverninental entity has special legal entitlements to use the bond-tinanced property i.uider an arrangement with the issuer. In general, a nongovernmental entity is treated as a private business user as a result of o�niership of bond- financed prpperty; actual or beneticial use of bond-�inaneed property pursuant to a lease, a management contract, or an incentive payment contract; or certain other arranQements such as a take or pay or other output-type contract. One of the most comtnon �vays in which private busincss use can occur is for a governmental entity to enter into a manageuiei�t or service contract with a nongover�itnental eniily� (hereinaiter a"service provider") under which 2he service pro��ider will provide ser��ices at a bond-financed facility. Both Congress and the internal Revenue Service (the °IRS") appe�ar to recognize that it is neither feasible noc desirable to ban these types of contracts. They have instead regulated these contracts, especially as to their tenn �nd compensation provisions, to ensure that an undue portion of the bene�fits of tax-eYempt financing will not accrue to the service provider. In Febniary 1997, the IRS published Revenue Procedure 97-13, �vhich it modified and amplitied in Revenue Yrocedure 2001-39 and �otice 2014-67 (collectively, the "Revenue Procedure"} to provide a safe harbor to allow governmental entities to enter into management or 63693469.1 service contracts without creating private business use of a bond-financed facility. The Revenue Procedure focuses primarily on the term and compensation provisions of such contracts. Please note t�iat this document is a summary of the Re��enue Procedure and does not address every provision thereof. This document is priinarily designed for governniental entities with bond-financed property that is not anticipated to be used for the provision of inedical services. Notice 2014-67 contains ccrtain peo�•isions specific to situations encountered under the Affordable Care Act, which are not covered herein. I�ationall}�-recog7lized bond counsel shouid be consulted �vith questions about the application of the Revenue Procedure to particular sit��ations. TYPES UF CU�'I'1zAC'1'S COV�:KE:ll Before the publication of the Revenue Procedure, most bond counsel recognized that a contract providing for the management of au entire bond-fiiianced facility must be re.stricted or private business use would result. But tl�ere was disagreement about whether cantracts for services ancillary to the purpose of a bond-financed facility were subject to regulation. For e�ample, could a food service a�rcement or an equipment service contract result in pri��ate business use? "1'he Revenue Procedure defines a"manage�nent contract" to mean ca mnrzcagerrte�zt, ser•vice, o�� i�zce�ative pay�r:ef�f contr•act between �a governntental per�sonJ crnd a ser•vice py�ovider idnde�� tivhich tlte cef•vice provic�er provicles set���ices irivolving all, cr portion of; or an��,fi.�nction r�f. a(hond-financecfJ facilin�. F�or exarnple, a cor:tr•act for the provision of trtanagement set-vices f�r an entis-e hospital, a cont��act fo� »zanagement services for• a specific depar�rna�nt of' u h�st�itczl, anc� a�z incentive �a�%ment contract fof• physiciara ser�vicc�s to patients of a hospital are each treated as a mancxgement contract. Whereas pi-ior law had detined a management contract to include a contract for "janitorial services at a hospital," lhe Revenue Procedure specifically excludes "�cJontracts for services that are solely incidental to the primary ... function or functions of a financed facility (for example, contracts for janitorial, oftiee equipment r�pair, hospital billiug or similar services)." I�PORTANT DEFINITI�NS 1'he following definitions are important in applying the Revenue Procedure to various types of management contracts: (1) "Adjusted gross revenues" means gross revenues of all or a portion of a facility, less allowances for bad debts and contractual and similar allowances. (2) "Capitation fee" means a�ixed periodic amount for each person for whom the service provider or thc govcrnmental entity assumes the responsibility to provide all needed services for a specified period so long as the quantity a��d type of services actually provided to -�- covered persons variNS substantially. 1�'or exarnple, a capitation fee includes a fixed dotiar amount payable per month to a medical service pr�vider for each member of a health maintenance organization plan for wh�m tlie provider agrees to provide all needed medical services for a specified period. A fi�ed periodie amount may include an automatic increase according to a specified, objective, e�tel�lal standard that is not linked to the output or efficiency of a facility. For example, the Consumer Frice Inde� and similar e�ternal indices that track increases in prices in an area or increases in revenues or costs in an industry arc objective, external standards. A capitation fee may include a variable component of u� to 20 percent of tlie total capitation fee designed to protect the service provider against risks such as catastrophic loss. (3) "Periodic fixcd fce" mcans a statcd dolla�• amount for services rendered for a specitied period of time. �'or example, a stated dollar amount per month is a periodic fited fee. The stated dollar amount may automatically increase according to a specilieci, objective, external standard that is not linked to the output or efficiency of a facility. For example, the Consumer Price Index and similar external indices that track increase�s in prices in an area or increases in revenues or costs in ar� industry are objective external sta,ndards. Capitation tees and per-unit fees are not periodic tixed fees. (4) "Aer unit fee" means a fee based on a unit of service provided. For example, a stated dollar amount for each specified medical procedure perfonned, car parked, or passen�er mile is a per-unit fee, Separate billing arr�u-igements between ph��sicians and hospitals generally are treated as per-unit fee arrangements. A fee that is a stated dollar amount specified in the contract does not fail to be a per-unit fee as a result of a pmvision under which the fee may automatically increase according to a specified, oUjective, external standard that is not linked to the output or efficieney of a facility. For example, the Consumer Price In�leY and similar external indiccs that track increases in prices in an area or increases in revenues or costs in an industry are objective, e�ternal standards. (5) "Rene���al option° means a provision under which a party to a contract has a legally enforceable right to renew th� contract. A provision under which a contract is automatically rencwed for one-year periods absent cancellatiQn by either party is not a renewal option (even if it is expected to be renewed). GE�ERAL COMPENSATION RESTRICTIO�S Reasonableness and No Net Profits. [Inder thc Revenue Procedure, a management contract must provide far reasonable compensation for services rendered. A key indicia of private business use is a proprietary interest in the operation of a bond- financed facility. Thus, a management co�ltract must not provide for any compensation to the service provider for services based, in whole or in part, on a share of net profits from the. operation of the facility. "1'he Revenue Procedure does permit compensation based on a percentage of gross revenues (or adjusted gross revenues) �f a f'acility or a percentage of expenses of a facility, but not both. -3- Pennissible Yroductivity Awards. The Revenue Procedure genera�ly pei-�nits a productivity reward equal to a slated clullar amount based on increases in gross revenues (or adjusted grass revenues), or reductions in total expenses (but not both) in any annual period during the term of the contract. A prodt�ctivity reward for scrvices in any annual period during ihe tenn of the contract generally also does not cause the compensation to be based on a share of net profits of the financed facility i£ • The eligibility for the productivity award is based on the quality of the services provided iuider the managemcnt contract (for c�ample; the achievement of Viedicare Shared Savings Yrogram quality performance standards or meeting data reporting requirements), rather than increases in revenues or decreases in expenses of the facility; and • The amount of the producti�-ity av��ard is a stated dollar amount, a periadic iised fee, or a tiered system of stated dollar amounts or periodic fixed fees based solely on the level of performance achieveci with respect to the applicable measure. Pennissible Reimbursements. Excluded from the restrictions on compensation is reirnbursement of the ser��ice pravider for any actual and direct e�penses paid by the service provider to unrelated parties. SAFE HAItBUIt CQMYENSATIO:� ARIlANGEMENTS I'he compensation arranoemeiit must fall into one of the following categories-- Categorv A-- 9� percent periodic fi�ed fee arran�ements. At least 95 percent of the annual compensation for services is based on a periudic tixed f'ee. A fee may include a o�ie-time incentive award during thc t�rm of the contract under «�hich compensatiun automatically increases when a gross revenue or expense target (but not both) is rcachcd, as long as the a�n�ard is equal to a single, stated dollar amount. Categary B-- 80 percent periodic fised Iee arrazi�e�iient_s. At least 80 percent of the annual compensation for services is based on a periodic ftxed fee. A fee may include a one-time incentive a�°ard during the term of the contract under wl�ich coml�ensation automatically increases when a gross revenue or e�pense target (but not both) is reached, as lo��g as the award i� equal to a single, stated dollar amount. Categor_y� C-- 50 percent periodic fixed fee arran�ements. At least Sp percenl of the annual compensation for services is bascd on a periodic tiYed fee. The most commonly encountered siluation under Category C. is where a serviee provider receives an annual fixed fee and then is "incentivized" to ma,�imiae die gross revenues of a bond-financed faciliry by receieing a percentage of the gross revenues "capped" at a dollar amount equal to the annual fi�ed fee. Cate�ory D-- Capitation_ fee arrangements. All of the compensation to the service provider is based on a capitation fee or a combinati�n of a capitation fee. and a periodic fixed fee (which periodic fixed fee is less than 50 percent of the annual compensation). -4- Cate�or�E -- Per Unit_Fee .�lrrangements. All of the compensation is based on a per-unit fee or a combination of a per-unit fee anci~a periodic fitied fee (�vhich periodic fixed fee is less than 50 percent of the annual compensation). The amount of the per-unit fee must be speci tied in the service contract or otherwise specifically detei�nined b�� the governmental entity or an independent third party. Cate�orv F-- Percenta�e oi' fees char�;ed arrangements. All af the compensation for services is hased on a percentage of fees charged or a combination of a per-unit fee and a percentage of revenue or espense fee. This Category applies only to ntanagement contracts under ���hich the service provider priinarily provides services to third parties. '1`he most common example of a Category F mana�ement contract is the typical physician contract, under which a physician or group of ph��sicians agrees �vith a�iospital to provide, for eaample, radiology services to tl�e hospital's patients. "i'he hospital bills the patient for and collects the non- professional fees and charges. The ph}'sician or physician's group bills the patient for and collects all (i.e., 100%) of the professional fees. Cate�y G-- Percentage of revenue or ex�ense fee arran ements. All of the compensation is based on a percentage of g�•oss revenues, adjusted gross revenues or e�penses of the bond-financed facility. This Category applies only to mana�ement contracts involvin� a facility durin� an initial start-up ��eriod i'or which there have been insufficient operations to establish a reasonable estimat� of the amount of annual gross revemies and expenses. The compensation arraugement inust be altered to Gt one of tlie other seven coinpensation categories after tl�e initial start-up period. Cate�ory H— Tiered productivitv award arranTements. All of the compensation for services is based on a stated amount; periodic fixed fee; a capitation fce; a per-unit fec; or a combination of' the preceding. The compensation for services also may include a percentage of gxoss revenues, adjusted gross revenues, or expenses of the facility (but not both revenues and e�penses). For ptu-poses of this Cate�ory H, a tiered �roductivity award ���ill be treated as a stated aniount or a periodic fiYed fee, as appropriate. TERM AND CANCELLATION SAFE HARBOR REQUIRENIENTS The Revenue Procedure unposes specific ternl and cancellation requirements on management contracts. These requirements vary as to the applicable compensation arrangement catcgory. Categories A and R. The tercn of a Category f1 nlanagement contract, including all rec�ewal options, must not exceed the lesser of 15 years or 80 percent of the etpected useful lifc of the boiici-iinanced facility. "1'he term of a Category 13 management contract, including all renewal options, must not e�ceed the lesser of 10 years or 80 perceni of the e�pected useful life of the bond-financed facility. Neither category of management contract contains a cancellation requirement. Cate�ories C and D. The terni of a Category C or D management contract must not e�ceed five years, including all rene��-a1 aptions. A Category C or D contract musl be cancelable -5- by the governmental entity upon reas�nable notice at the end of the third year of the contract term, without penalty or eause. The Reve��ue Proc�edure does not define "reasonablc notice." Cate�;<�r�. The term of a Category E. management contract must not cxcced three years, including all rene��al options. The governmental entity must be able to cancel a Category E contract at the end of the second year of the coniract tenn upon reasonable notice and without penalty or cause. Cate�ories F and G. The maximum ter�n of a Category F or G management contract is two years, including all rcnewal options. A Cate�ory F or G contract must be cancelable by the governmental entity on reasonable notice, without penalty ar cause, at the enci oC �he lirst year of the contract term. Cate��orti� H. The maximum tertn of a Category IC management contract, including all renewal o�tions, is fi��e ycars. Such contract need not be terminable b5� the governmental entity prior to t�le end of the term. Cancellation without penalty or_ cause. 'l he Revenue Yrocedure giv�s the following c:aamples of contract terminatio�� penalties: (l ) a lin�itation on the governinental entity's right to compete with the service providor; (2) a requircment that the governinental entit�� purchase equipment, goods a�id services from the service provider; (3) a requirement tliat the governmental entity pay liquidated dama�es for cancellation of the management contract; and (4} another contract between the service provider and the governmental e��tity, if that ccmtract contains tcrms that arc not customary or arni's-length that could operate to prevent the governmental entity from terminating the contract (for eY�nple, a contract thal places substantial restrictions on the selection of a substitute service provider}. RI+:STRTCTIONS ON REI.ATED PARTIES ANll C01�1MON CONTROL The Revenue Procedure generally prohibits any relationship or arrangement bet��een the go��ernmental entity and the service provider "that, in effect, substantially limits the [govenunental entity's] ability to exerrise its rights, including cancellation rights, under the �managementJ contract." The Revenue Procedure provides tllat a relationship �vill be deemed not to limit substantially the governmental entity's ability to elercise its rights if: (i) not more than 20 percent of the voting power of the goveming body of the governmental entity is vested in the service provider and its directors, ofticers, sharehulders ana employees, (iij overlapping board members do not include the chief executive officers of the service provider or its governing body or the govcrnmental entity or its governing body, and (iii} the governmental entity and the service provider are not "related persons" or members of the same "controlled ��roup," as those terrns are delined in the Code and the Treasur}� Re�ulations. -6-