April 1, 2015 - Resolution to Adopt Chp 1: Personnel, Art. V, Sec. 5.14 & Amend Chp 1: Personnel, Art. VI, Sec. 6.4 RESOLUTION TO ADOPT CHAPTER 1: PERSONNEL, ARTICLE V,
SECTION 5.14 AND AMEND CHAPTER 1: PERSONNEL, ARTICLE VI,
SECTION 6.4, CHAPTER 1: PERSONNEL, ARTICLE VII AND ARTICLE
VIII OF THE COUNTY POLICY MANUAL
WHEREAS, the County has established guidelines regarding the
provision of paid leave types for employees and desires to adopt a new
additional employee paid leave type of Recognition Leave under Chapter 1:
Personnel, Article V, Section 5.14 of the County Policy Manual; and
WHEREAS, the County has established guidelines regarding the
provision of the Virginia Retirement System benefit, disciplinary policy and
procedures, and grievance policy and procedures under Chapter 1: Personnel,
Article VI, Section 6.4, Article VII, and Article VIII of the County Policy
Manual; and
WHEREAS, the Board of Supervisors desires to amend Chapter 1:
Personnel, Article VI, Section 6.4, Article VII, and Article VIII of the County
Policy Manual to clarify the provisions, guidelines, rules and procedures for
the provision of Virginia Retirement System participation, discipline, and
grievances; and
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that Chapter 1: Personnel,
Article V, Section 5.14 is adopted and Chapter 1: Personnel, Article VI,
Section 6.4, Article VII, and Article VIII of the County Policy Manual is
hereby amended as follows:
Chapter 1 : Personnel
ARTICLE V
Leave Provisions
(Revised September 1, 2005, December 15, 2005, February 2, 2006,
April 5, 2007; October 2, 2008; January 8, 2009; June 19, 2014, October 16, 2014,
December 18, 2014, April 1, 2015)
Section 5.14
(Adopted April 1, 2015)
Recognition Leave
All personnel are eligible to receive leave hours for the purpose of such instances as the recognition
of service to the County, in conjunction with the promotion of or participation in safety,health, or
wellness initiatives, or for any other purpose approved by the County Administrator. Recognition
leave is intended to provide employees paid leave separate and apart from his/her other available
paid leave types.
For the purpose of the recognition of five years of service milestones with the County, the
following schedule will apply:
Years of Service Number of Recognition Leave Hours Awarded
5 4
10 8
15 12
20 16
25 20
< 30 24
Recognition leave is non-cumulative, must be taken within 90 calendar days of it being granted,
and any remaining balance thereof shall be forfeited at the end of the 90 calendar day period. Any
recognition leave shall not be paid upon separation of employment,is non-transferrable, and is not
compensable in the form of monetary compensation in lieu of paid leave time. Use of recognition
leave hours must be scheduled and approved in advance by the employee's immediate supervisor.
Recognition leave shall be granted to an employee for a specific purpose by the Human Resources
Department upon approval of the County Administrator or his/her designee. The Human
Resources Department shall inform the employee's department director that such recognition leave
has been granted.
ARTICLE VI
Benefits
(Revised January 17, 2002, September 1, 2005, December 15, 2005, October 16, 2006,
October 4, 2007, November 15, 2007, July 1, 2008, December 4, 2008, November 20, 2014,
December 18, 2014, April 1, 2015)
Section 6.4
(Revised December 15, 2005, October 4, 2007, April 1, 2015)
Virginia Retirement System
The County shall provide membership in the Virginia Retirement System(VRS)in the appropriate
state retirement plan for all employees who are eligible under the rules and regulations of the
system. Employees are required to contribute to the applicable plan in which they are enrolled and
the County pays the employer contribution on behalf of the employee, which varies based on the
applicable plan. ' - . . -- • - - • - •- - . - • • - - - . . - - • !
ARTICLE VII
Disciplinary Policy
(Revised February 2, 2006, April 1, 2015)
Section 7.0
(Revised February 2, 2006, April 1, 2015)
Disciplinary Policy
There is an exemplary standard of conduct expected of each employee of the County. It is
generally interpreted to mean that an employee will conduct himself/herself in a manner
compatible with public service. It is also the responsibility of the employee to perform his/her
duties to the best of his/her ability and to the standards set forth in the job description. County
employees also have the duty and responsibility to be aware of and abide by existing policies,
procedures, rules and regulations. No employee shall be disciplined for political or religious
reasons or for any other unlawful cause.Where practical,the County's disciplinary procedure shall
be progressive in nature.
Supervisor Responsibility
The immediate supervisor must approach corrective measures in an objective manner. If the
employee's performance of an assigned task is the issue, the supervisor should generally look to
see that proper instructions, appropriate orientation, and training have been given and that the
employee is aware of job expectations. Not only single incidents, but also patterns of poor
performance should be of concern as these are indicative of overall performance. If misconduct is
the issue, the supervisor should take steps to insure the employee has been made aware of the
County's policies and regulations regarding the infraction.Disciplinary actions should also include
a plan for correction that is clearly communicated with the employee.
Section 7.1
Purpose
The purpose of this disciplinary policy is to provide supervisors with a fair and objective guide for
determining the seriousness of an employee's unsatisfactory work performance or misconduct and
selecting the appropriate disciplinary action to correct the unacceptable behavior.
Section 7.2
(Revised April 1, 2015)
Definitions
Verbal Oral Reprimand - A verbal oral reprimand shall be defined as a discussion between the
supervisor and the employee where the employee is advised and cautioned about his/her
unsatisfactory work performance or misconduct. In order to officially be recorded as an oral
reprimand, the oral reprimand shall be documented on the County's Employee Corrective Action
Form and placed in the employee's personnel file. Oral reprimands are not grievable. No oral
reprimand shall be given without prior approval by the department of Human Resources.
Written Reprimand - A written reprimand shall be defined as a-written documentation to the
employee from the supervisor wherein the employee is advised and cautioned about his/her work
performance or misconduct. The written reprimand shall be documented on the County's
Employee Corrective Action Form and placed in the employee's personnel file. No written
reprimand shall be given without prior approval by the department of Human Resources.
Suspension-A suspension shall be defined as the temporary temporarily prohibiting an employee
from performing his/her duties as a result of the employee's unsatisfactory work
performance or misconduct. An employee may be suspended without pay for a period not to
exceed 15 workdays with the approval of the department of Human Resources. The suspension
period shall be without pay. With the approval of the County Administrator, an employee may be
suspended for a longer period. The suspension shall be documented on the County's Employee
Corrective Action Form and placed in the employee's personnel file. No suspension shall be given
without prior approval by the department of Human Resources.
Disciplinary Demotion - A disciplinary demotion shall be defined as . -• . • - -- .. : ..
• - - . - - - • :- - •-• : . •- • . - -- • •- . The reassignment of an employee
to a lower pay grade. An employee who receives a disciplinary demotion shall receive a decrease
in salary with the approval of the department of Human Resources. The disciplinary demotion
shall be documented on the County's Employee Corrective Action Form and placed in the
employee's personnel file. No demotion shall be valid without prior approval by the department
of Human Resources.
Dismissal - A dismissal shall be defined as an involuntary separation from employment initiated
by the County empleying-autherity as a result of the employee's unsatisfactory work performance
or misconduct. The dismissal shall be documented on the County's Employee Corrective Action
Form or in some other approved written manner and placed in the employee's personnel file. No
dismissal shall be valid without the prior approval by the department of Human Resources.
Section 7.3
Applicability
All employees within departments which are a part of the classified service shall be covered under
this policy. All levels of supervision shall be responsible for the uniform orientation of employees
regarding this policy and its fair and equal enforcement.
Section 7.4
(Revised April 1, 2015)
Policy
The County supports the use of progressive discipline to address conduct issues such as poor work
performance or misconduct and to encourage employees to become more productive workers and
meet County standards and expectations.
The County reserves the right to administer appropriate disciplinary action for all forms of
disruptive and/or inappropriate behavior. Each situation will be dealt with on an individual basis.
The County has established general guidelines to govern the conduct of its employees. No list of
rules can include all instances of conduct that can result in discipline and the examples below do
not replace sound judgment or common sense behavior.Examples of employee conduct that would
lead to discipline and the usual course of disciplinary action have been separated into three groups,
according to the severity and impact of the infraction. Violations may warrant differing levels of
discipline depending on the level of seriousness. The severity of the discipline chosen by the
supervisor must be proportionate to the seriousness of the offense. The County always reserves
the right to determine the appropriate level of disciplinary action, including but not limited to
disciplinary demotion,oral and written warnings reprimands,suspension,and dirge dismissal.
For inadequate or unsatisfactory job performance,the supervisor may,with approval of the County
Administrator, place an employee on probationary status. In the event the employee has not
achieved satisfactory performance by the end of the probationary period,he/she may be discharged
in accordance with the provisions of Section 4.9. Below are some examples of offenses that may
lead to disciplinary action.The list is not meant to be all-inclusive or in any way limit the County's
ability to take disciplinary action for offenses not included on this list.
First Group Offenses (Examples Only)
• Unsatisfactory attendance or tardiness;
• Abuse of County time, such as:
o Unauthorized time away from work area; or
o Failure to notify supervisor promptly of completion of assigned work
o Abusing lunch meal periods
• Obscene or abusive language;
• Contributing to unsanitary or unsafe conditions
• Violating the chain of command as described in Article VIII concerning issues arising in
the workplace
Second Group Offenses (Examples Only)
• Failure to follow supervisor's instructions,perform assigned k duties timely,correctly,
competently, or at an adequate level of production or otherwise comply with applicable
established written policy;
• Insubordination;
• Incompetency or inefficiency;
• Leaving the work area without proper notice to supervisor;
• Unauthorized use or misuse of County property or records;
• A moving traffic violation while using County vehicles;
• Violating safety rules where there is not a threat to life;
Third Group Offenses (Examples Only)
• Absence or leave in excess of three (3) work days without a satisfactory explanation;
• Use of alcohol or unlawful use or possession of controlled substances while on the job, or
reporting to work when under the influence of alcohol or controlled substances;
• Falsifying any records such as,but not limited to: vouchers,reports,insurance claims,time
records,leave records, or other official records;
• Willfully or negligently damaging or defacing County records or County or employee
property;
• Theft or unauthorized removal of County records or County or employee property;
• Acts of physical violence or fighting;
• Engaging in sexual activities while on the job or on County property;
• Violating safety rules where there is a threat to life;
• Sleeping during working hours;
• Willful dereliction of duty
• Participating in any kind of work slowdown, sit down, or similar concerted interference
with County operations;
• Unauthorized possession or use of firearms, dangerous weapons or explosives;
• Threatening or coercing employees or supervisory personnel;
• Criminal convictions for acts of conduct occurring on or off the job which are related to
job performance or are of such a nature that to continue the employee in the assigned
position could constitute negligence in regard to the department's duties to the public or to
other County employees;
• Violations of the County's Non-Discrimination and Anti-Harassment Policy;
• Demonstrating insubordination, including but not limited to:
o Refusal to do an assigned job
o Refusal to work overtime when required
o Refusal to accept holiday work when assigned
o Intentional delay in carrying out an assignment
Supervisors may account for mitigating circumstances in determining discipline, but they must
document any such mitigating circumstances in writing.
All disciplinary actions, with the exception of verbal oral reprimand, are appealable through the
grievance procedure.
Procedural steps for imposing discipline are set forth on the following pages. The failure of a
supervisor to follow these procedural steps will not, of itself, render the discipline invalid or
improper. However,the supervisor's failure to follow the procedure may be separately grieved by
an employee and may be included in an evaluation of the supervisor's job performance.
Section 7.5
(Revised April 1, 201 5)
Reprimands
Reprimands are given for offenses which are less severe in nature but which require correction in
the interest of maintaining a productive and well-managed work force. The form of the reprimand
may be either verbal oral or written.
a. A supervisor should first discuss the offense with the employee and advise him/her of the
need for correction. If the situation is not corrected, the employee should be given an
Employee Corrective Action Notice designating the reprimand as either an Oral or Written
Reprimand and emphasizing the need for correcting his/her behavior. written notice to
b. No reprimand shall be relied upon as a basis for further disciplinary action unless it is
documented in writing and a copy forwarded to the Human Resources Department for
inclusion in the employee's official personnel file.
c. Once a reprimand is reduced to writing, as provided above, a copy shall be hand delivered
and signed"received"by the employee or mailed to the employee yee by certified mail (return
receipt requested) if hand-delivery is not practical.
d. W.
T • T Reprimands shall be cumulative in nature and shall remain on file. After-three
•
and
Section 7.6
(Revised April 1, 201 5)
Suspensions
Suspensions are given for acts of conduct of a more serious nature, including unsatisfactory work
performance or misconduct,which continues after discipline has been imposed. Corrective action
for these offenses include a meeting between the employee and the supervisor, if possible,prior to
the suspension being imposed, a written notice including the items listed below and suspension
without pay. Employees may not be suspended in excess of fie fifteen (5 15) work days for an
offense of this nature.
Prior to suspending or dismissing an employee, the department director or supervisor must:
a. Meet with the employee to discuss the problem and provide the employee an
opportunity to respond in written form by the close of the next business day;
b. Review the employee's responses and any available information regarding the
problem; and
c. Prepare a written statement of the problem,the employee's response, a summary of
findings, action being taken, a warning to what further disciplinary action could result if
the situation is not corrected and a statement of the employee's right to appeal (if any) in
accordance with the County's grievance policy.
A written notice of suspension shall be hand delivered and signed received or mailed certified mail
(return receipt requested) to the employee. The items listed below shall be included in the written
notice:
a. A statement of the reason(s) for the suspension;
b. A warning of what further disciplinary action could result,if the situation is not corrected;
c. A statement of the employee's response to the reasons for the suspension as indicated in
the meeting between the supervisor and the employee; and if a meeting was not possible
prior to the suspension being imposed,the reason that a meeting could not take place should
be stated in the letter.
d. A statement of the employee's right to appeal (if any) in accordance with the County's
grievance procedure.
A copy of such written notice shall be forwarded to the Human Resources Department for inclusion
in the employee's official personnel file. • - . . . •. t. . - . .• •- _ . . .
Section 7.7
(Revised April 1, 2015)
Disciplinary Demotion
Disciplinary demotions can occur as an intermediate discipline or as an alternative to termination
in second or third group offenses,or in cases of continued commission of first group offenses after
discipline has been imposed.
a. An effort should be made by the supervisor to meet with the employee prior to imposing the
demotion. The employee should be given the opportunity to respond to the reasons for the
proposed action.
b. A written notice of the demotion shall be hand delivered or mailed to the employee by certified
mail (return receipt requested). The items listed below shall be included in the written notice.
1. A statement of reasons for the demotion;
2. In cases where the demotion is not voluntary,a warning of what further disciplinary
action could result, if the situation is not corrected;
3. A statement of the employee's response to the reasons for the demotion as indicated
in the meeting between the supervisor and the employee; and if a meeting was not
possible prior to the demotion,the reason that a meeting could not take place should
be stated.
4. A statement of employee's right to appeal (if any) in accordance with the County's
grievance policy, unless the demotion is voluntary.
c. A copy of such written notice shall be forwarded to the Human Resources Department for
inclusion in the employee's official personnel file.
d. A demotion shall not be used as a disciplinary action if the employee involved cannot
qualify for the lower-ranked position or if the demotion would require the displacement of
another employee.
Section 7.8
Dismissal
An employee is dismissed for acts and behavior of such a serious nature that a first occurrence
should normally warrant termination and for unsatisfactory performance or misconduct of a less
serious nature which continues after discipline has been imposed for prior poor work performance
or misconduct.
An effort should be made by the supervisor to meet with the employee prior to the dismissal. The
employee should be given the opportunity to respond to the reason(s) for the proposed action. A
written notice shall be hand delivered or mailed certified mail (return receipt requested) to the
employee if hand-delivery is not practical. The items below shall be included in the written notice.
1. A statement of the reason(s)for dismissal;
2. A statement of the employee's response to the reasons for the dismissal as indicated
in the meeting between the supervisor and the employee; and if a meeting was not
possible prior to the dismissal,the reason that a meeting could not take place should
be stated in the letter;
3. A statement of the employee's right to appeal (if any), in accordance with the
County's grievance policy.
A copy of such written notice shall be forwarded to the Human
Resources Department for inclusion in the employee's official personnel file.
Section 7.9
(Revised April 1, 2015)
Additional Non-Disciplinary Suspension Provisions
In addition to the suspensions provided for in the preceding pages, suspensions with or without
pay may occur for the following reasons, subject to the limitations noted.
a.
. •. .
b. Immediate Suspension
Nothing in this policy shall prevent the immediate suspension with-pay of an employee
whose continued presence on the job is deemed to be a substantial and immediate threat to
the welfare of the employee's department or to the welfare of the public, or where such
continued presence could constitute negligence in regard to the department's duties to the
public or to other County employees. Such suspension may be imposed in any of the these
following situations with the prior approval of the affected department director or his/her
designee,Director of Human Resources or his/her designee and the County Administrator
or his/her designee. Where such suspension must be imposed at a time other than normal
working hours, the County Administrator shall be notified and consulted at the beginning
of the next work day.
c. Suspension Pending Court Action or Official Investigation
An immediate suspension with-pay shall be warranted where there is a criminal prosecution
or official investigation involving alleged criminal violations that occur on or off the job
and are related to job performance or are of such a nature that to continue the employee in
the assigned position could constitute negligence in regard to the department's duties to the
public and to other County employees.
Upon completion of such court action or official investigation, the employee may be
disciplined or removed or may be reinstated.The County Administrator shall not be bound
by the outcome of court action or official investigation but may refer to such outcome and
the findings in making a final decision. (Official investigation shall be interpreted to
include only those investigations conducted by Federal, State or local government law
enforcement agencies.)
d. Suspension Pending Department Disciplinary Investigation
An immediate suspension with-pay may be imposed pending completion of a disciplinary
investigation into misconduct or violation of established work rules; provided, however,
that before such a suspension is imposed the department director must find that the
employee's continued presence on the job would present a substantial and immediate threat
to the welfare of the department or the public, or that it could constitute negligence on the
part of the County in regard to the department's duties to the public or to other County
employees. Such suspension shall not exceed ten (10) work days in length. Such
suspension may be imposed in any of these situations with the prior approval of the affected
department director or his/her designee, Director of Human Resources or his/her designee
and the County Administrator or his/her designee. Where such suspension must be
imposed at a time other than normal working hours, the County Administrator shall be
notified and consulted at the beginning of the next work day.
If the employee is cleared of any such alleged violations, the employee shall be reinstated.
Section 7.10
Mitigating Circumstances
Mitigating circumstances include those conditions related to a given offense that would serve to
support a reduction or corrective action in the interest of fairness and objectivity. Mitigating
circumstances may also include consideration of an employee's length of service with a history of
satisfactory work performance.
Section 7.11
Not All Inclusive
The offenses listed in this policy are not intended to be all-inclusive. Accordingly,conduct which,
in the judgment of the department director, although not listed, seriously undermines the
effectiveness of the agency's activities or the employee's performance,should be treated consistent
with provisions of this policy. A record of such offenses must be filed with the Director of Human
Resources and County Administrator.
Section 7.12
Right to Grieve Disciplinary Action
All regular full-time and regular part-time employees in the classified service,who have completed
their probationary period, may grieve disciplinary actions in accordance with the grievance
procedure in Article VIII.
ARTICLE VIII
Grievance Procedure
(Revised June 14, 2007, April 1, 2015)
Section 8.0
(Revised April 1, 2015)
Policy
Isle of Wight County desires to resolve employee grievances fairly and promptly. Employees are
encouraged to freely discuss their concerns with immediate supervisors and upper management
levels when disagreements or dissatisfactions arise. The County shall strive for equitable treatment
of all employees and by doing so attempt to alleviate the occurrence of grievances. Most issues
may be resolved through discussion, but alternatives are necessary when discussion is not
effective.
Section 8.1
(Revised April 1, 2015)
Purpose
The purpose of a the County's grievance procedure is to establish an objective and fair method of
resolving an employee's complaint or dispute concerning his/her employment with the County by
allowing employees to bring their concerns to upper levels of management. All problems,
complaints or disputes, even of a minor nature, should be resolved with the least amount of delay.
It is the County's intent that this policy comply fully with state law. In cases of conflict, the laws
of the Commonwealth of Virginia shall govern. Questions concerning the grievance procedure
should be directed to the Human Resources Department.
Section 8.2
(Revised April 1, 2015)
Applicability
Unless otherwise provided by law, all non-probationary local government permanent regular full-
time and part-time employees are eligible to file grievances with the following exceptions:
a. Appointees of elected groups or officials;
b. Officials and employees who by statute, ordinance or other law serve at the will or
pleasure of the Board of Supervisors;
c. Deputies and executive assistants of the County Administrator;
d. Agency, —ef department heads, of chief executive officers, or Assistant County
Attorneys of County operations;
e. Employees whose terms of employment are limited by law;
f. Temporary, limited term and seasonal employees;
g. Law enforcement officers as defined in Chapter 10.0(Section 2.1-116.1 et seq.)of Title
2.1 of the Code of Virginia whose grievance is subject to the provisions of Chapter 10.0
and who have elected to proceed pursuant to the provisions in the resolution of their
grievance, or any other employee electing to proceed pursuant to any other existing
procedure in the resolution of his/her grievance;
h. Firefighter and Emergency Medical Technicians who elect to proceed under the
Firefighter and Emergency Medical Technicians Procedural Guarantee Act, section
9.1-500 et seq. (sometimes known as the firefighter's bill of rights);
i. Members of boards and commissions;
j. Volunteers;
k. Constitutional Officers;
1. Consultants and legal counsel rendering professional services;
m. Probationary employees;
n. Individuals whose employment with the county has been terminated as a result of
resignation, reduction in force, or retirement.
Notwithstanding the exceptions set forth above, the County, at its sole discretion, may voluntarily
include employees in any of the excepted categories within the coverage of their grievance
procedures.
Section 8.3
(Revised April 1, 2015)
A. Definition of Grievance
A grievance shall be defined as a complaint or dispute by an employee relating to his/her
employment,but not necessarily limited to the following grievable issues:
b. The application or interpretation of personnel policies, procedures, rules, regulations, and
d. Complaints of discrimination on the basis of race, color, creed, political affiliation, age,
•
(1) The disciplinary actions of written reprimand, disciplinary demotions, dismissals,
and suspensions;
(2) Concerns regarding the application, meaning, or interpretation of personnel
policies, procedures, rules, and regulations;
(3) Discrimination in any employment practice based on the employee's race, color,
creed, sex, age, religion, national origin, disability or political affiliation;
(4) Acts of retaliation as the result of the use of or participation in the grievance
procedure or because the employee has complied with any law of the United
States or of the Commonwealth of Virginia,has reported a violation of such law
to a governmental authority,has sought any change in law before the
Congress of the United States or the General Assembly, or has reported an
incidence of fraud, abuse, or gross mismanagement.
B. Management Responsibilities
Management reserves the exclusive right to manage the affairs and operations of County
government. Accordingly the following complaints are not grievable under this procedure:
a. Establishment and revision of wages or salaries,positions, job titles
or general benefits;
b. Work activity accepted by the employee as a condition of employment or work
activity which may reasonably be expected to be a part of job content;
c. Contents of ordinances,statutes or established personnel policies,procedures,rules
and regulations;
d. Failure to promote except where the employee can show that established
promotional policies or procedures were not followed or applied fairly;
e. The methods, means and personnel by which work activities are to be carried on;
- . . - . •. . . .. • •: -; Termination, demotion or suspension
from duties because of lack of work, reduction in workforce, or job abolition,
except where such action affects an employee who has been reinstated within the
previous six (6) months as a result of the final determination of a grievance. Such
action shall be upheld upon a showing that: (i) there was a valid business reason
for the action and (ii) the employee was notified of such reason in writing prior to
the effective date of the action;
g. The hiring, promotion, transfer, assignment and retention of employees within the
County;
h. The relief of employees from duties of the County in emergencies.
i. Counseling memoranda and manners of providing supervisory directions;
j. Performance evaluations;
k. Oral reprimands.
In any grievance brought under the exception to provision (f) of this subsection, the action shall
be upheld upon a showing by the County that:
1. There was a valid business reason for the action; and
2. The employee was notified of the reason in writing prior to the effective date of the
action.
Section 8.4
(Revised June 14, 2007, April 1, 201 S)
Grievance Procedure
Most employee concerns or complaints can be resolved informally through communications
between the employee and his/her supervisor. Accordingly, employees are encouraged to take
their complaints to their immediate supervisor and then to upper management levels to seek a
solution. Employees are also encouraged to pursue grievable issues through the grievance
procedure.
Step 2. If the grievance is not resolved at the first step, the employee shall state in writing
• , •
and the department director within seven (7) calendar days aftcr rcccipt of the
present if he/she so desires. The department director or Assistant County
grievance, the employee and the County Administrator may have a
direeter.
_ . . . . . _ . . . . • . - ,
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
(a) The procedure f o r grievance a
includes the following steps:
(1) Step 1. An employee who has a complaint shall discuss the problem
directly with the employee's immediate supervisor within twenty (20)
calendar days of the date the employee should have reasonably gained
knowledge of the event giving rise to the complaint. The employee is not
required to present the complaint in writing at this step. A verbal reply
by the supervisor shall be made within five (5) business days following
the meeting. Failure on the part of the employee to initiate the action
required within the time stated herein shall terminate the employee's
right to initiate a grievance on that issue.
(2) Step 2. If the complaint is not resolved after the first step, the employee
may submit in writing the complaint to the employee's immediate
supervisor within five (5) business days of the supervisor's verbal reply in
step 1. The complaint shall be made using the "Grievance/Remedy Form"
available from the department of human resources. The immediate
supervisor shall reply in writing on the "Grievance/Remedy Form" to the
complaint within five (5) business days of the receipt of the written
complaint and provide a copy to the department director and the department
of human resources. If the County Administrator or the County
Administrator's designee is the immediate supervisor, steps 2, 3 and 4 are
consolidated into one step. Failure on the part of the employee to initiate
the action required within the time stated herein shall terminate the
employee's right to continue a grievance on that issue.
(3) Step 3. If the complaint is not resolved in step 2, the employee may
appeal the decision of the supervisor to the department director by
forwarding the "Grievance/Remedy Form" to the department director
within five (5)business days of receipt of the immediate supervisor's
written response in step 2. The department director shall reply in writing
on the "Grievance/Remedy Form" to the complaint within five (5)
business days of the receipt of the written complaint and provide a copy to
the department of human resources. Failure on the part of the employee to
initiate the action required within the time stated herein shall terminate the
employee's right to continue a grievance on that issue.
(4) Step 4. If the complaint is not resolved at step 3, the employee may appeal
the decision of the department director by forwarding the
"Grievance/Remedy Form" to the County Administrator or County
Administrator's designee within five (5) business days of the department
director's response. Within five (5) business days of its receipt, the County
Administrator or County Administrator's designee shall meet with the
grievant and the department director together,to discuss the grievance. The
County Administrator or County Administrator's designee shall reply to the
grievant on the "Grievance/Remedy Form"within five (5)business days of
the discussion and provide a copy to the department of human resources.
Failure on the part of the employee to initiate the action required within the
time stated herein shall terminate the employee's right to continue a
grievance on that issue.
(b) With the exception of step 4, the only persons who may be present in the
management step meetings are the employee, the employee's immediate supervisor or department
director depending on the level at which the grievance is being heard, and appropriate witnesses
for each side. Witnesses shall be present only while actually making his or her statement. At step
4, the employee, at his or her option, may have present a representative of his or her choice. If the
employee is represented by legal counsel, the county likewise has the option of being represented
by counsel. The employee must notify the County Admininistrator and the Human Resources
Department of the name of his or her attorney within five (5) calendar days of the scheduled
meeting. The presence of attorneys shall not alter the fact that this is an administrative, informal,
fact-finding process involving, in step 4, a meeting and discussion between the County
Administrator or County Administrator's designee and the employee.
Section 8.5
(Revised June 14, 2007, April 1, 2015)
Panel Hearing
panel.
- - -•.. . , -.. - , - ., . ., - - -, - • _, - -, • - - , ., . - . ` . . • -
.. _ --- - , _ - . - , . . - - - .. . •
present-at-the-meeting:.
proceeding;
• The majority decision of the panel, acting within the scope. of its authority, shall be final,
a
• Copies of the panel's decision shall be transmitted to the employee, the cmployee'a
Request for Hearing
If the County Administrator's or the County Administrator's designee's response does not
resolve the grievance at step 4,the grievant may request a hearing before a grievance panel. The
request for a hearing shall be submitted in writing to the Director of Human Resources within
five (5)business days of the response of the County Administrator or the County Administrator's
designee.
Panel Composition
(1) In cases of employee termination or retaliation, the panel shall be made up of three
impartial members. Two panel members shall be chosen from employees of the County. One of
those panel members shall be appointed by the employee and one shall be appointed by the
County Administrator or County Administrator's designee. The third panel member shall be an
administrative hearing officer who is appointed by the Executive Secretary of the Supreme
Court. The County will pay all costs related to the use of the hearing officer. The administrative
hearing officer shall act as panel chairperson.
(2) In all other cases, the panel shall be made up of three impartial members chosen from
employees of the County, one appointed by the grievant, one appointed by the County
Administrator or County Administrator's designee, and a third panel member selected by the first
two appointed panelists, who will serve as the panel chairperson. In the event that an agreement
cannot be reached as to the third panel member, the chief judge of the circuit court of the County
shall select the third panel member.
(3) All County employees, as a condition of County employment, shall serve on grievance
panels, whether selected by the grievant, management, or by the two appointed panelists to serve
as the panel chair. All employees of the Human Resources Department, Office of the County
Attorney, and the County Administrator's office shall be excluded from serving on the panel.
(4) The panel shall not be composed of any persons having direct involvement with the
( ) P P YP g
grievance being heard by the panel, or with the complaint giving rise to the grievance; nor
managers who are in a direct line of supervision of the grievant; nor employees in the same
department as the grievant; nor persons who are residing or have resided in the same household
as the grievant; nor the following relatives of either participant in the grievance process: spouse,
parent, grandparent, child, grandchild, sibling, step-sibling, in-law, niece, nephew or first cousin.
No attorney having direct involvement with the subject matter of the grievance, nor a partner,
associate, employee or co-employee of the attorney shall serve as a panel member. Panel
members chosen in compliance with these requirements shall be deemed to be impartial.
(5) The County Administrator or County Administrator's designee, the grievant, or the
grievant's department director may challenge the eligibility of the other party's panel member by
requesting a determination from the Director of Human Resources of whether the selection has
met or violated the eligibility requirements. Such requests must be made in writing no fewer than
five (5)business days prior to the date of the scheduled panel hearing. If one member is found to
be ineligible,the remaining members are unaffected. If at all possible, an immediate replacement
will be impaneled and the hearing conducted as scheduled.
Rules for Panel Hearings
The conduct of panel hearings as a part of the grievance procedure shall be governed by the
following rules:
(1) The panel does not have authority to formulate policies or procedures or to alter existing
P Y P P g
policies or procedures;
(2) The panel has the discretion to determine the propriety of attendance at the hearing of
persons not having a direct interest in the hearing, and, at the request of either party, the hearing
shall be P rivate;
(3) The County shall provide the panel with copies of the grievance record prior to the
hearing, and provide the grievant with a list of the documents furnished to the panel;
(4) The grievant and his or her attorney, at least ten (10) calendar days prior to the scheduled
panel hearing, shall be allowed access to and copies of all relevant files intended to be used by
the County in the grievance proceeding;
(5) The panel shall have the authority to determine the admissibility of evidence without
regard to the burden of proof, or the order of presentation of evidence, so long as a full and equal
opportunity is afforded to all parties for the presentation of their evidence;
(6) All evidence shall be presented in the presence of the panel and the parties, except by
mutual consent of the parties;
(7) The documents, exhibits and lists of witnesses shall be exchanged between the parties in
advance of the hearing;
(8) The panel hearing is an administrative process and is not meant to be conducted like
proceedings in court. Panels are not bound by rules of evidence and shall take into account all
reliable and substantial evidence produced at the hearing. It is within the province of the panel to
determine relevancy and materiality. The panel may require either party to demonstrate
relevancy and materiality of any evidence and the need for any requested extensions of the
hearing panel;
(9) The panel shall deal with the grievance before them. Evidence and testimony as to how
other employees or situations have been handled in the past are not relevant except in cases of
discrimination. Previous applications of the same policy may be relevant. No personnel file or
record may be examined by the panel or introduced into evidence,except that of the grievant;
(10) The panel has no subpoena power to compel the attendance of witnesses. The panel may,
however, at the request of either party, or in its own discretion, request the voluntary appearance
of witnesses or the submission of documents.
Authority of the Panel Chair
The chair, acting on behalf of the panel, has the authority to:
(1) Issue requests for witnesses or documents but does not have subpoena power;
(2) Administer oaths;
(3) Receive documentary evidence and hear testimony, and exclude that which is irrelevant,
immaterial, repetitive or confidential by law;
(4) Decide on procedural requests;
(5) Hold a conference (in person or by telephonic means) to simplify the issues, decide
procedural matters, discuss settlement possibilities, and establish the date, time, and place of
hearing; and
(6) Order the parties to exchange a list of witnesses and documents.
Conduct of the Hearing
(1) The hearing must be held within 30 calendar days of the selection of the panel in a
location convenient to where the employee is or has been employed. The County must arrange a
place for the hearing unless the panel chair chooses to make the arrangements. It is the
responsibility of the panel chair to notify the parties, either in writing or at a prehearing
conference, of the date, time and place of the hearing.
(2) When a hearing is scheduled, it is the responsibility of the parties to appear or ask for a
postponement. A hearing may proceed in the absence of one of the parties; a hearing so
conducted will be decided on the grievance record and the evidence presented at the hearing. The
parties may be represented by legal counsel or other representative, or may represent themselves.
A hearing may be continued into evenings or weekends. The panel may grant a postponement or
extend the 30 calendar day period for good cause.
(3) Opening and closing statements may be made by each party. Each party may be
represented by an individual of choice. All witnesses, except for the grievant and a representative
of the County, shall not be present in the hearing room except when giving testimony. Exhibits
may be offered into evidence and be made part of the record. The hearing must be recorded
verbatim. The panel chair is responsible for the recording and is to preserve the recorded tapes as
a part of the grievance record. Either party may receive a copy of the recording at cost. A court
reporter is not required. If either party requests a court reporter, that party is responsible for the
costs. If a transcript is made, the other party may request a copy at cost. The panel chair has the
authority to determine the propriety of the attendance of all persons not having a direct
involvement in the hearing including witnesses and spectators. The hearing shall be closed to the
public.
Decision
(1) The panel's decision must be in writing and contain the findings of fact and the basis for
those findings. The panel shall deliver its decision to the Director of Human Resources, the
individual who represented the County during the panel hearing and the employee within ten
(10)business days of the conclusion of the hearing unless the panel by majority vote extends the
time period. If the panel extends the time period for its response, the panel chair shall notify the
parties in writing. The majority decision of the panel, acting within the scope of its authority,
shall be final, subject to existing policies, procedures and law.
(2) The panel shall decide the case on the merits, not on whether there has been compliance
with the procedural requirements of this article. The panel does not have the authority to
formulate policies or procedures nor to alter existing policies and procedures. The panel shall
make its decision within the following standards of review:
a. In grievances involving disciplinary action for misconduct, including termination
for misconduct, the panel shall uphold the County if the evidence shows that the
charge(s) of misconduct and disciplinary action(s) were more likely than not appropriate
under the circumstances. If the panel finds that the charge(s) or disciplinary action(s)
were not appropriate under the circumstances, then the panel has the same authority and
limitations as management to determine the appropriate charge(s) or disciplinary
action(s) in accordance with applicable County policy. The panel may not impose a
disciplinary action in excess of the original disciplinary action imposed by the County.
b. In grievances involving termination for unsatisfactory work performance, failure
to meet job standards, unacceptable attendance or other nondisciplinary matters, the panel
shall uphold the County's action if it determines that the action was more likely than not
appropriate under the circumstances. If the panel finds that the charge(s) or disciplinary
action(s) were not appropriate under the circumstances, then the panel has the same
authority and limitations as management to determine the appropriate charge(s) or
disciplinary action(s) in accordance with applicable County policy. The panel is not
empowered to establish or modify job standards,job requirements, or performance
standards nor may the panel determine or change an employee's evaluation rating. The
panel may not impose a disciplinary action in excess of the original disciplinary action
imposed by the County.
c. In grievances involving complaints regarding application of policy, discrimination
and other nondisciplinary issues, the panel will determine if policies and procedures have
been appropriately applied. If the panel finds that the policies and procedures have not
been applied appropriately, then the panel, as appropriate relief, may issue an order to
create an environment free from discrimination or to take corrective actions necessary to
cure the violation and/or minimize its recurrence. The panel is not empowered to
promote, assign or transfer employees, to establish salaries nor to take any other action
which is in the purview of management rights.
d. The panel does not have the authority to consider matters which the grievance
procedure makes nongrievable.
e. The majority decision of the panel, acting within the scope of its authority, shall
be final, subject to existing policies, procedures and law.
f. The panel may not award damages or attorney's fees.
(3) Within ten (10) business days of the receipt of the panel's decision, the Director of
Human Resources will review the decision and may on his or her own action remand a decision
which appears to be inconsistent with law and written policy to the panel for further
consideration. All parties will be notified if a decision is remanded.
(4) The County Administrator shall implement the panel decision to the extent that it is
consistent with the provisions of law and written policy. Either party may petition the circuit
court of the County for an order requiring implementation of the panel decision.
Section 8.6
Determination of Grievability
1. Determining Issues Qualifying for the Management Steps
If the first or second step written management response indicates that a given issue is not grievable,
an employee may appeal to the County Administrator,or his designee,who is empowered to render
a decision on the grievability and on the access of the procedure of issues in the management steps.
Neither the County Attorney nor the Commonwealth's Attorney shall be authorized to decide the
question of grievability. If the County Administrator finds that the issue is grievable,the grievance
may be pursued through the three management steps. However if the County Administrator or his
designee, finds that the issue is not grievable, the employee may appeal to the Circuit Court for a
hearing on the issues as to whether or not the grievance qualifies for a panel hearing. The appeal
procedure shall be in accordance with subsection 2 below.
If the issue qualified by the court, the management step process should be completed before
proceeding to panel (unless the grievance is otherwise resolved).
2. Determining Issues Qualifying for a Panel Hearing
Decisions regarding whether or not a matter qualifies for a panel hearing shall be made by the
County Administrator at the request of the department director or grievant and such decisions shall
be made within ten (10) calendar days of such request. Such requests shall be made in writing.
Such decisions of the County Administrator may be appealed to the Circuit Court for a hearing on
the issues as to whether or not the grievance qualifies for a panel hearing. Proceedings for review
of the decision of the County Administrator shall be instituted by filing a written notice of appeal
with the County Administrator within ten(10) calendar days thereafter,the County Administrator
shall transmit to the Clerk of the Circuit Court to which the appeal is taken a copy of the decision
of the County Administrator,a copy of the notice of appeal,and the exhibits. A list of the evidence
furnished to the Court shall be furnished to the grievant. The failure of the County Administrator
to transmit the record within the time allowed shall not prejudice the rights of the grievant.
The court on motions of the grievant, may issue a writ of certiorari requiring the County
Administrator to transmit the record on or before a certain date. Within thirty (30) calendar days
of receipt by the Clerk of such records, the Court sitting without a jury, shall hear the appeal on
the record transmitted by the County Administrator and such additional evidence as may be
necessary to resolve any controversy as to the correctness of the record,the Court,in its discretion,
may receive such other evidence as the ends of justice require. The Court may affirm the decision
of the County Administrator or may reverse or modify the decision. The decision of the Court
shall be rendered no later than the fifteenth (15th) day from the date of the conclusion of the
hearing. The decision of the Court is final and is not appealable.
Section 8.7
Following the Procedure
After the initial filing of a written grievance, failure of either party to comply with all substantial
procedural requirements of the grievance procedure without just cause will result in a decision in
favor of the other party on any grievable issue,provided the party not in compliance fails to correct
the noncompliance within five (5) work days of the receipt of written notification by the other
party of the compliance violation. Such written notification by the grievant shall be made to the
County Administrator. Failure of either party without just cause to comply with all substantial
procedural requirements at the panel hearing shall result in a decision in favor of the other party.
This procedure is provided as a means for employees to resolve problems and complaints without
the cost often associated with legal counsel. However,if any employee using the procedure would
feel more comfortable in having such support, the employee shall be responsible for related
expenses.
Adopted this 1St day of April, 2015.
I ' f . Alphin, Chairman
Carey Mil s Storm, Clerk
Appr•ve► as t• form:
■ ark C. Pop e,- ch, County Attorney