8-17-23 - (#23-009) Ordinance Issuing CUP-6-22 for Carver Solar I, LLC (Various Tax Map #'s) ORDINANCE NUMBER a3 " � "I
AN ORDINANCE TO ISSUE A CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT FOR A 71 MW
UTILITY SCALE SOLAR ENERGY GENERATION FACILITY AND
SUBSTATION, ON 637 ACRES OF PROPERTY WITH TAX MAP PARCELS 52-
01-028, 52-01-034, 52-01-035, 52-01-036, 45-01-059, 45-01-059A, 45-01-061,45-01-
061B,45-01-061C, 45-01-065, 45-01-068, 52-01-037, 52-01-039, 53-01-001, 53-01-003,
53-01-003M,53-01-006, 53-01-022,53-01-022E,AND 46-01-019A
WHEREAS, Carver Solar I, LLC, applicant, and Carter R. Clements, Joyce G. Clements, Travis
w. Williams, Lewis Clarence Lee Trust (Clarence Lee Lewis, Trustee), Joshua Pretlow, Jr., Garrison
Farm Solar LLC, Delman Lew Carr Trust (Delman Lew Carr, Trustee), Chester G. Carr Trust (Glenn and
Susan S. Carr, Trustees), Helene Johnson Hobbs, Joest Properties, LLC, Scott L. Thomason, Carla A.
Thomason, James K. Edwards, Marsha F. Edwards, Cobb Land Limited Parmership, Troy L. Robinson,
and Margaret F. Robinson, property owners, have requested approval of a conditional use permit for a 71
MW utility-scale solar energy facility and substation on 637 acres located on tax parcel numbers 52-01-
028, 52-01-034, 52-01-035, 52-01-036, 45-0 l-059, 45-01-059A, 45-OI-061,45-01-061 B, 45-01-061 C, 45-
01-065, 45-01-068, 52-01-037, 52-01-039, 53-01-001, 53-01-003, 53-01-003M, 53-01-006, 53-01-022,
53-01-022E, and 46-01-019A, which land is depicted on Exhibit "B"; and,
WHEREAS, the procedural requirements of Appendix B, Zoning Ordinance, of the Code of Isle
of Wight County,Virginia, 2005 (as amended), have been followed; and,
WHEREAS, in acting upon this request, the Planning Commission and Board of Supervisars
have considered the matters enunciated in Section 15.2-2284 oi�the Code of Virginia (1950), as amended,
and Section 1-1017 of the Isle of Wight County Zoning Ordinance with respect to the purposes stated in
Code of Virginia(1950), as amended, Section 15.2-2200 and l52 2283; and,
WHEREAS, the Planning Commission has made a recommendation as stated in Exhibit "A;"
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED by the Isle of Wight County Board of
Supervisors of Isle of Wight County, Virginia, that:
Section I. Exhibits.
Exhibit "A", "Planning Commission Recommendation", Exhibit "B", "Property Map", and
Exhibit "C" Conditions which are attached hereto, are hereby incorporated as part of this
ordinance.
Section 2. Findines.
The Board of Supervisors finds that the proposal for conditional use permit CUP-6-22, as
submitted or modified with conditions herein, the expressed purpose of which is to permit a major
utility service, is in conformity with the standards of the Isle of Wight County Zoning Ordinance,
and that it will have i�o more adverse ePfects on the hcalth, safety or comfort of pa•sons living or
wurking in or driving through the neighborhoud, an�l will be nu more injurious tu property ur
improvements in the neighborhood than would any other use generally permitted in the same
district, taking into consideration the location, type and height of buildings or structures, the type
and extent of landscaping and screening on site and whether the use is consistent with any theme,
action, policy or map of the Comprehensive Plan with the conditions set forth below.
These findings are based upon the consideration tior the existing use and character of the property,
the Comprehensive Plan, the suitability of' the property for various uses, the trends of growth or
change, the current and future requirements of the community as to land for various purposes as
determined by population and economic studies and other studies, the transportation requirements
of the community, the requirements of airports, housing, schools, parks, playgrounds, recreation
areas and other public services, the conservation of natural resources, the preservation
floodplains, the preservation of agricultural and forestal land, the conservation of properties and
their values, and the encouragement of the most appropriate use of land throughout the County.
These findings are based upon a determination that most reasonable and limited way of avoiding
the adverse impacts of a major utility service is by the imposition of the conditions provided
herein.
Section 3. Permit Gra�ted.
The conditional use permit for the property be, and is hereby approved for the property, subject to
the attached conditions in Exhibit "C" and the general conditions set forth in Section 4 hereof.
The conditional use permit specifically allows for a major utility service in compliance with the
County Zoning Ordinance.
Section 4. Severabilitv.
It is the intention of the Board of Supervisors that the provisions, sections, paragraphs, sentences,
clauses, and phrases of this ardinance are severable; and if any phrase, clause, sentence,
paragraph, section, and provision of this ordinance hereby adopted shall be declared
unconstitutiona] or otherwise invalid by the valid judgement or decree of a court of competent
jurisdiction, such unconstitutionality or invalidity shall not affect any of the remaining phrase,
clauses, sentences, paragraphs, sections, and provisions of this ordinance, to the extent that they
can be enforced notwithstanding such determination
Section 5. Effective Date
This ordinance shall be effective upon passage and shall not be published or codified. The
conditional use authorized by this permit shall be implemented within two (2) years from that
date of approval by the Board of Supervisors and shall terminate if not initiated within that time
period.
This ordinance shall be effective upon passage and shall not be published or codified.
DATE: �'��' ZO 2.3
'°°�.
READ AND PASSED:
Chairman, Boar f Supervisors
�W lX C.(J6.�
TESTE:
Clerk,Board of Supervisors
Approv d as t For :
Robert W.Jones Jr, o � ty Attorney
i
EXHIBIT A
RESOLUTIOh' NU1�IBER PG22-15
ISLE OF WIGHT COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION
A RESOI,UTION TO PRESENT A REPORT�1ND RECO:�iMENDATION
TO THE BOARD OF SC'PERVISORS RF.I,�TING TO CONDITIONAL L'SE PERMIT
REQUEST CUP-06-22 TO ALLOVV A MAJOR t�TII.IT�' SF,RV"ICF;,SPECIFICALLY A 71 11t�L'
UTILITY SC�LE SOLAR ENERG�' GENERATION FAC[L[TY A�D SUBSTATION,Or`637
ACRES OF PROPERTY WITH TAX 1tAP PARCELS 52-01-028,52-01-U3�,52-UI-035,52-01-036.
45_p1-059,45-01-059A,4�-01-061,45-U1-061K.45-01-061C.45-01-065,45-01-068,_52_01-037,52-Oi-
039,53-U1-W1,53-01-003,53-01-003!�1,S3_01-006,S3-01-022,53-01-022E,AND 46-01-019A
WHEREAS,Carver Si�lar I, LLC, applicant, and Carter R. Clements, Jc�yce G. Clements, Tra�is
W. Williams, Lewis Clarence Lee Trust(Clarence Lee Lewis,Trustee),Joshua Pretlow, Jr..Garrison Farm
Sular LLC. Delman Lew Carr Trust(Delman Lew Carr.Trustee), Chester G. Carr Trust (Glenn and Susan
S. C�ur.Trustees). Helene Johnson Hobbs.Joest Pruperties. LLC, Scott L. Thomason,Carla A.Thomason,
James K. Edwards. Marsha F. Eclwards. Cobb Land Limited Partnership, Truy L. Robinson. and Mazgaret
F. Robinson,propeRy owners,has requested approval of a conditional use permit for a 7l MW utilit�-scale
solar energ}�facilit}� and substation on 637 acres located on tax parcel numbers 52-01-028, 52-01-03-i, 52-
01-035, 52-01-036, �35-01-0Sy, �35-01-05yA, �35-0 I-061,45-01-061 B, �5-01-(K�I C. 45-0 l-OfiS, 45-01-068,
52-01-037. 52-01-039. 53-01-001. 53-0 l-(x)3, 5 i-O l-(x)�M. 5 3-U I-O(�i. 53-01-022. 53-0 I-022E. and 46-
01-019A situatcd in Isle of Wight Count}: and
WHEREAS, thc spccitic reyuest is to permit a major utility service, specifically a utiliry-scale
solar energy generation facility and substation, in accordance with sections I-1017 and 5-5(Xl3 of the
7.oning Ordinance;
WHEREAS the procedural requirements f�r the rcrosideration of thi, request by the Planning
Cc�mmission ha��e heen me�.
NO�L',THEREFORE,BE IT RF:SOI.VF,D by the Planning C��mmissicm of Isle of V1'ight County,
I�litl:
Sectiun I. FindinQs.
�/ , .
A. The Isle of Wight Count� Planning Commistiion finds that the proposed c�mditional use
permit is reasonable and has considered the following facton and finds that the proposed
use does not cc�nflict with:
1. the existing use and character of property w•ithin the County;
2. the Comprehensive Plan;
3. the suitability of the property for various uses;
-1. thc trcnds of gro�•th or changc;
5. the current or fuwre rcquircments of the community as to land for various purposes
as detern�ined by population and economic studies and other studies:
6. the transportation requirements of the cc�mmunity:
7. the requirements for airport�. housing, school�. parks, playgrounds, recreation
areas and other public services;
8. the c��nsen�ati�m c�f natural res��urres:
9. the preservation of floc�plains;
]0. the preservation of�agrirultural an�l forestal land:
1 I. the ronservation of pruperties and their values: and
l?. the encouragement c�f the most appropriate use of land thre►ughout the County.
B. The Isle uf Wight County Planning Commissiun does not find that the proposed use is
reasonable based on the consi�ieration of the factors liste� herein.
Section 2. Recommendation to Board of Supervisors.
The Planning Commission recommends to the Board of Super��i�ors that the request. CL'P-O6-?2,
be:
__a. Grantcd as submitted, and that thc Board of Supervisors adopt thc proposcd Ordinancc
w�ithout moditication.
Denied, and that Board of Supen�ison not adopt the proposed(hdinance.
_c. Granted with the specitic recommended conditions in the attached exhibit, and that the
Q�ard�f Supen�isors adopt the proposed Ordinance with such ronditions.
DATE: �V O V �� . ���
READ Ati'D PASS '
airn�an. Isle of Wight County Planning Commission
TESTE:
, �^�r��
.
Secretar}. Isle of Wight County Planning Commission
Approved as to Fart :
�
Robert W. Jone� Jr County Attomey
' \. � / - �
�� � � �, �
CUP-6-22 Carver Solar �� ---�)/ � �� �- - . � � �
Pr M � /
opertY ap � � ,
' � --- ----_ �
; � �
EXHIBIT B ��
`--� � ���"�``��--"�-`"�----�
.� - � � �
� � � � �
. . � �
___ ,� ,
�%�� ; -
..`
�- -,.-.
� 115KV line %^
� � _...
! \
� �/'�� \�� —___ , .---' `
���.._� �� �� � ---- � � ��
�� - _"� '� �l��� � � �_ ,f� �
� � _ � � � ' i / � ___
�� � � dx;i'-� � —
� ���_� � � �� � � � � � � _ � �
�` /1 '��
1 �� � / '
/ '�--�.. .,`. ,
,�� � ~ -- `' r/ lJ
` � 1 ��''D'i � �l / /
l C� �_FJ `' � - � � � --�y � ._._,
. , -
,� ..\ ' � �---�•-'�_ --_
� - =`���.
_ (, ��
�L- �� �._ l.� qrP
/
...,-./��-.✓�J1J ���/'� � f � ASO
--�, � � ,
� , r _ ;
� � � __ �
Carver Solar�
N �
i _
� '' I �
- � —
- ..
i —.__._ . _ _
� /
EXHIBIT C
CARVER SOLAR CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL
ADOPTED BY THE ISLE OF WIGHT COUNTY BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
AUGUST 17, 2023
CUP-6-22
1. The portion of the subject property supporting solar panels shall be enclosed by security
fencing of a type that is harmonious with the rural, agricultural, and historical character
of the County while meeting federal and state regulations for solar electric generating
facility fencing as determined by the Zoning Administrator adjacent to all public rights-
of-way, residential property, properties eligible for listing on the National Register of
Historic Places, and civic uses prior to final site plan approval.
2. Fencing shall be placed around the solar arrays, inverters, and substation only and not the
whole site in order to provide wildlife corridors.
3. In order to minimize the visual impacts to historic, civic and residential properties, all
solar arrays, inverters, substations and other associated structures are subject to a
minimum 200 foot setback from these structures if part of the project and 200 feet from
the property line of these properties if outside the project, except as provided in
Conditions 18, 19 and 20.
4. Except as provided herein, the enhanced landscape buffer plan proposed on the concept
plan exhibit is conceptual only at this time. The landscape buffer design and required
plantings will be reviewed in detail for approval during site plan review and, at minimum,
must include a triple row of staggered evergreen and deciduous species meeting the
minimum specifications of the landscaping ordinance and of varying heights at maturity
where existing vegetation is not being retained. Trees shall be planted no more than ten
(10)feet on center. On Parcel ID No. 45-01-059 at the corner of Yellow Hammer Road
and Deerfield Drive, applicant shall establish 1,200 linear feet of six (6) rows of plantings
which is shown in the concept plan as "Double Enhanced Vegetation."This buffer
location and orientation will be reviewed in detail at site plan review but the design and
location as stated herein is binding upon the applicant and will only be modified at the
direction of the Director of Community Development. Along the boundary of Parcel ID
No. 53-01-022 that abuts Parcel ID Nos. 53-01-023 and 53-01-024, applicant shall
establish 600 linear feet of six (6)rows of plantings which is shown in the concept plan
as "Double Enhanced Vegetation." This buffer]ocation and orientation will be reviewed
in detail at site plan review but the design and location as stated herein is binding upon
the applicant and will only be modified at the direction of the Director of Community
Development.
5. The applicant shall permanently preserve and maintain existing and newly installed
buffer landscaping and shall not clear or cut live trees within required setbacks or buffer
zones except as necessary to avoid shading of solar panels as approved by the Zoning
Administrator.
6. Excluding the bufferyards described above, the ground between the panels and in areas
not otherwise covered by gravel or infrastructure shall be planted and maintained with a
vegetative cover. This vegetative cover will be managed with mowing and/or grazing.
7. The applicant shall meet any additional delineation and buffer requirements specified by
the Virginia Department of Historic Resources prior to receiving final site plan approval.
8. The applicant shall submit an Emergency Response Plan at the time of site development
plan application for review and approval by the County, which shall detail fire
suppression methods that will be immediately deployed during both construction and
operation of the facility. The plan shall include a training program to be provided to
emergency responders about safety for on-site incident response. Initiation and frequency
of training will be coordinated between the Department of Emergency Services and the
facility operatar. The applicant shall install a Knox Box or other remote access
technology at the facility to ensure emergency responders have access to the facility
should the need arise.
9. Hours of operation for construction activities to be limited to 7:00 am to 6:00 pm
Monday through Friday and 7:00 am to 5:00 pm on Saturdays. No construction is to
occur on Sundays.
]0. Topsoil will be conserved on site.
1 l. The applicant shall reimburse the County for reasonable costs related to retaining such
third-party inspectors as deemed necessary for project inspections.
12. Prior to site plan approval, the Applicant shall either adjust the site plan to avoid areas
that were determined potentially eligible for the National Register of Historic Places as
part of the Phase 1 Archaeological Survey ar shall undergo the appropriate Phase 2 close-
interval testing to determine if any material is eligible far listing.
13. As part of the site plan review, the Applicant shall provide documentation that the
selected panels and all power generating equipment onsite are"Tier 1" modules as
established by the most recent "PV Module Tier 1 List" issued by Bloomberg NEF or a
similar third-party analysis widely accepted in the solar industry. Additionally, the make
and model of the selected panels and all power generating equipment initially installed
and replaced on the site must qualify, for disposal purposes, as non-hazardous waste
under applicable U.S. Environmental Protection Agency tests (e.g. TCLP).
14. There shall be a sign posted with the contact information for the local project liaison.
15. No salvage value be added to the decommissioning surety bond.
16. If the land area being leased was under crop cultivation prior to lease, it shall be
maintained and cut annually during the growing season prior to August 1 until site
construction begins.
17. The inverters shall be set back a minimum of 500 feet from all property lines.
18. The substation shall be set back a minimum of 125 feet from all property lines external to
the project and shall be set back 250 feet from any non-participating residential
structures.
19. The setback from all solar arrays and other associated structures from Parcel ID No. 53-
O l-024 which contains a cemetery, shall be 100 feet.
20. The project fence shall be set back at least 340 feet from the northernmost corner of
Parcel ID No. 45-01-059 at the intcrsection of Dcerficld Drive and Ycllow Hammer Road
as depicted in the concept plan.
21. The applicant shall make commercial best efforts to source US-made panels and other
materials.
22. The applicant shall provide pollinator meadows.
23. The maximum area of prime soils and soils of statewide importance used for solar
facilities has yet to be met as of the date of approval of this CUP. Pursuant to the
approval of this CUP, this Project is deemed to have satisfied Article V, Section M(4)(k)
of the Isle of Wight Zoning Ordinance.
24. A sealed dry-waste container shall be maintained at the facility for the disposal of any
damaged solar panels throughout the life of the facility.
25. The applicant shall implement a program for the collection of baseline data establishing
pre-construction soil conditions for the production of row crops for the agricultural areas
within the project area. The program shall establish the relevant characteristics of the
topsoiL The baseline data shall be derived from field and laboratory testing of soil
conditions, including depth, density and quality from representative locations. Laboratory
testing shall be conducted by an accredited laboratory. Parameters for assessing soil
quality may include the following: infiltration rate, bulk density, water holding capacity,
pH, percent organic matter, cation exchange capaciry, Phosphorous/Phosphate (P),
Nitrogen (N), and Potassium/Potash (K). After 30 years of operation and again after 35
years of operation, soil conditions shall be determined for the same sampling locations
using the same parameters and the results used to plan soil restoration activities. After
equipment is removed as part of decommissioning, soil conditions shall be determined
for the same sampling locations using the same parameters. Soil restoration activities
shall be performed as necessary during operations or decommissioning to return soil
conditions to at least baseline conditions. The County will be provided with data of soil
conditions within 30 days after the receipt of results.
26. At least once per month during operations, litter that may have accumulated between the
fence and the right-of-way of Highway 460 shall be collected and disposed of.
27. The use of all pesticides, herbicides and insecticides shall be prohibited, except those that
are approved for commercial applications may be used pursuant to an approved herbicide
and/or insecticide management plan prepared by a licensed professional that is submitted
to, and approved by, the Zoning Administrator.